1What resists upliftThe shaft and the weight; not the base.
A pile is pulled upwards when the structure it carries is light against the forces on it: a tower or a mast under wind, a mooring or an anchor block, a basement slab below the water table, or the back piles of a cap under a large overturning moment (see the load on each pile). In compression a pile carries load by its shaft and its base. In tension the base gives nothing: the soil below the tip is unloaded as the pile rises, and the suction that may form there is short-lived and is not relied on. What holds the pile down is the friction or adhesion on its shaft and its own weight:
Qs,i is the shaft resistance of layer i in compression, fi its unit value, p the perimeter of the pile and ΔLi the length of the pile in the layer; χi is the ratio of the shaft resistance in tension to that in compression. Wp is the weight of the pile, effective (buoyant) below the water table. The GeoTerva pile group module leaves the weight out, which is on the safe side, and gives Tu, the shaft resistance in tension, as the tension capacity of one pile. The largest tension on a pile is compared with Tu/FS, or with the allowable tension of one pile when one is entered, whichever is less.
2The shaft resistance in tensionA clay layer in full, a sand layer at 0.75.
Clay. The shaft resistance of a pile in a saturated clay is worked out in total stress from the undrained strength cu, by the α method: f = αcu, with α for a driven pile from the curve against cu/pa and, for a bored pile, the drilled-shaft rule of O’Neill and Reese (1999), no friction over the top 1.5 m and the bottom diameter. A rapid pull mobilises the same undrained strength along the shaft as a rapid push, so the module takes a clay layer in tension at its full resistance in compression:
Sand. In a sand the unit skin friction is f = Kσ′vtanδ′ (see pile skin friction in sand), with the values the GeoTerva pile modules fill in:
σ′v is the vertical effective stress, held constant below the critical depth L′ = 15D. A pile pulled out of a sand carries less shaft resistance than the same pile pushed in: as the pile rises it unloads the sand around its upper part, and the pile itself contracts slightly across its section under tension (the Poisson effect), so the normal stress on the shaft falls. Load tests and analyses (for example De Nicola and Randolph, 1993) show the shaft resistance in tension to be a fraction of that in compression, and the module takes a sand layer in tension at 0.75 of its resistance in compression. Where uplift is the governing load, for a mast or an anchor pile, a tension load test on a trial pile is the reliable check.
3Table of the tension capacity of one pileD = 0.50 m, L = 8–30 m.
| L (m) | L/D | Sand φ′ = 32°, driven: Qs in compression (kN) | Sand, driven: Tu (kN) | Sand, bored: Tu (kN) | Clay cu = 40 kPa, driven: Tu (kN) | Clay cu = 80 kPa, driven: Tu (kN) | Clay cu = 80 kPa, bored: Tu (kN) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | 16 | 200 | 150 | 107 | 372 | 543 | 415 |
| 10 | 20 | 285 | 213 | 152 | 465 | 679 | 553 |
| 12 | 24 | 369 | 277 | 198 | 558 | 814 | 691 |
| 15 | 30 | 496 | 372 | 266 | 697 | 1018 | 898 |
| 20 | 40 | 708 | 531 | 379 | 930 | 1357 | 1244 |
| 25 | 50 | 920 | 690 | 493 | 1162 | 1696 | 1590 |
| 30 | 60 | 1132 | 849 | 606 | 1395 | 2036 | 1935 |
Sand: γ = 18 kN/m³ above the water table at 2 m and 20 kN/m³ below it, K–δ method, σ′v held constant below 15D = 7.5 m, Tu = 0.75Qs. Clay: α method (driven: interpolated values after Terzaghi, Peck and Mesri, 1996; bored: O’Neill and Reese, 1999), Tu = Qs. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile group module uses.
Below the critical depth the shaft resistance in sand grows only in proportion to the length, because σ′v is held constant there; in a clay of uniform strength it grows in proportion to the length from the top. The bored pile in sand takes K = K0 instead of 1.4K0, so its tension capacity is about 1/1.4 of the driven pile’s. In the clay of cu = 80 kPa the two adhesion factors are close (α = 0.54 driven, 0.55 bored), and the bored pile carries less because it loses its top 1.5 m and its bottom diameter.
4Piles in tension in a groupThe piles, and the block of soil around them.
When several piles of a group are in tension, the module checks them together in two ways and takes the lesser. As individual piles, each layer’s tension resistance is reduced by the efficiency of the group in that kind of soil (the Converse–Labarre equation in a clay, the rules for driven or bored piles in a sand):
As a block, the piles in tension and the soil between them are lifted together, held by the weight of the block and by the shear on its four sides, as in the block failure of a group in compression but without a base:
Lt and Bt are the sides of the rectangle that encloses the piles in tension, to the outside of the outer piles; zc is the depth of the base of the cap; W is the weight of the soil in the block, effective below the water table. The sum of the tensions on those piles is compared with Tg/FS. A single pile in tension has no block of its own.
On the faces of the block the soil shears soil, so τ is the full strength (cu, not αcu), and the block adds its weight; each pile, on the other hand, takes a reduced shaft resistance. The block therefore governs only when many piles in tension stand close together. Table 2 shows square groups of driven piles under a moment that puts the rows behind the centroid in tension. In the sand at s = 2D the block governs from the 10 × 10 group upwards; at 3D, and in the clay, the piles govern in every group of the table.
| Group | Piles in tension | Sand, s = 2D: Tind | Sand, s = 2D: Tblock | Sand, s = 3D: Tind | Sand, s = 3D: Tblock | Clay, s = 2D: Tind | Clay, s = 2D: Tblock |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 × 2 | 2 | 399 | 917 | 399 | 1152 | 723 | 2024 |
| 4 × 4 | 8 | 1595 | 2591 | 1595 | 3862 | 2286 | 5526 |
| 6 × 6 | 18 | 3589 | 4618 | 3589 | 7365 | 4689 | 9581 |
| 8 × 8 | 32 | 6381 | 6998 | 6381 | 11663 | 7932 | 14189 |
| 10 × 10 | 50 | 9970 | 9731 | 9970 | 16755 | 12015 | 19350 |
| 12 × 12 | 72 | 14357 | 12817 | 14357 | 22642 | 16939 | 25064 |
Driven piles D = 0.40 m, L = 12 m. Sand: φ′ = 32°, γ = 18/20 kN/m³, water table at 2 m, η = 1 for driven piles below φ′ = 40°. Clay: cu = 50 kPa, γ = 18 kN/m³, Converse–Labarre efficiency. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile group module uses.
For the smallest group the block is 2.3 times the piles; for the 12 × 12 group in sand at 2D the ratio is 0.89.
5Worked exampleA cap under a large moment.
A cap stands on twelve driven concrete piles, D = 0.50 m and L = 16 m, in 3 rows of 4 at s = 1.50 m (s/D = 3.0) both ways. The ground is a medium dense sand from 0 to 6 m (φ′ = 32°, γ = 18 kN/m³ above the water table at 2 m, 20 kN/m³ below it) over a firm clay with cu = 60 kPa and γ = 18.5 kN/m³. The cap carries V = 2400 kN and, from the wind on the structure, My = 4200 kN·m; FS = 3.
- The loads on the piles. Σx² = 18.0 m², so the back row at x = −1.50 m takes P = 2400/12 − 4200 × 1.50/18.0 = −150.0 kN: its 4 piles are in tension, Tmax = 150.0 kN and ΣT = 600.0 kN. The front row takes 550.0 kN in compression.
- One pile in tension. The shaft resistance of each layer in compression and in tension:
| Layer | Soil | Parameters | f (kPa) | Qs (kN) | χ | T (kN) | η in the group |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–6 m | sand | K = 0.658, δ′ = 24.0°, σ′v = 43.6 kPa | 12.77 | 120.4 | 0.75 | 90.3 | 1.000 |
| 6–16 m | clay | α = 0.62, cu = 60 kPa | 37.20 | 584.3 | 1.00 | 584.3 | 0.710 |
| Total | 704.7 | 674.6 |
p = πD = 1.571 m. In the sand L′ = 15D = 7.5 m lies below the layer, so σ′v is the mean over the layer.
- Tu = 90.3 + 584.3 = 674.6 kN (in compression the same pile carries Qu = Qs + Qp = 704.7 + 106.0 = 810.7 kN). Tu/FS = 224.9 kN against Tmax = 150.0 kN: OK.
- The 4 piles as individuals. Tind = 4 × (1.000 × 90.3 + 0.710 × 584.3) = 2020 kN.
- Their block. Lt = 0.50 m (one row), Bt = 5.00 m, Pb = 11.00 m. Sand: τ = K0σ′vtanφ′ = 0.470 × 43.6 × tan 32° = 12.80 kPa, 12.80 × 11.00 × 6 = 845 kN. Clay: τ = cu = 60 kPa, 60 × 11.00 × 10 = 6600 kN. Weight: W = LtBtσ′v(16 m) = 0.50 × 5.00 × 163.7 = 409 kN. Tblock = 7854 kN.
- The group in tension. Tg = min(2020, 7854) = 2020 kN, the piles govern; Tg/FS = 673 kN against ΣT = 600 kN: OK.
The pile in tension uses 67 % of its allowable tension. The clay carries most of it: the sand layer gives only 90.3 kN of the 674.6 kN. The pile group module of GeoTerva does these checks whenever a moment puts piles in tension, beside the compression checks of the front piles and of the group.
6QuestionsShort answers.
Does the base of a pile resist uplift?
No. The soil below the tip is unloaded as the pile rises; the suction that can form under the base is short-lived and is not counted. The tension capacity is the shaft resistance in tension plus the weight of the pile, and GeoTerva leaves the weight out, on the safe side.
Why is the uplift capacity of a pile in sand lower than its shaft capacity in compression?
Pulling the pile unloads the sand around its upper part and narrows the pile slightly under tension, so the normal stress on the shaft falls. GeoTerva takes the shaft resistance of a sand layer in tension as 0.75 of its value in compression; a clay layer, worked out in total stress, is taken in full.
When does the block govern the uplift of a pile group?
Only when many piles in tension stand close together: the faces of the block take the full strength of the soil and the block adds its own weight, while each pile takes a reduced shaft resistance. In Table 2 it governs only for the larger groups of driven piles in sand at s = 2D.