GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Stress distribution

Westergaard stress distribution: compared with Boussinesq

The vertical stress in a soil whose thin, stiff horizontal layers prevent lateral strain: Westergaard’s point load, circle and rectangle, their influence factors side by side with Boussinesq’s, and when each applies.

  • Free to read
  • r/z = 0–3
  • Point · circle · rectangle
  • Worked example

1Westergaard’s mediumSoft soil between rigid sheets.

Boussinesq’s solutions assume a homogeneous, isotropic half-space. Many deposits are layered instead: varved and laminated clays, or soft soil with thin, stiffer seams that restrain its horizontal deformation. Westergaard (1938) solved the point load for an idealisation of such a soil: an elastic material reinforced by numerous thin, rigid horizontal sheets that permit no lateral strain. Its single parameter is Poisson’s ratio μs of the soil between the sheets, through

η=1−2μs2−2μs

For μs = 0, η = 1/√2 = 0.7071; as μs approaches 0.5, η tends to zero and the solution breaks down.

2The point loadΔσz = (P/z²)·IW.

A point load P on the surface raises the vertical stress at depth z and horizontal distance r by

Δσz=Pz2IW,IW=12πη2[(rηz)2+1]−3/2

which for μs = 0 becomes

IW=1π[2(r/z)2+1]−3/2 against IB=32π[(r/z)2+1]−5/2

for Boussinesq (see Boussinesq point load). Directly below the load IW = 1/π = 0.3183 against IB = 0.4775: the rigid sheets spread the load sideways. Both distributions carry the whole load P through any horizontal plane, so what Westergaard takes from the axis it places farther out: beyond r/z = 1.52 its stress is the larger. A larger μs concentrates the load again; at μs = 0.4, IW on the axis is 0.9549, above Boussinesq’s value. The Westergaard point load module gives the stress of several point loads at once.

3The circle and the rectangleIntegrated over a loaded area.

Integrated over a uniformly loaded flexible area q, the point-load solution gives two closed forms. Below the centre of a circle of radius R:

Δσz=q[1−ηη2+(R/z)2]

and below a corner of a rectangle B × L, with m = B/z and n = L/z as for Boussinesq’s corner factor I3 (see stress below a rectangular footing):

Δσz=qIWc,IWc=12πtan−1[(η2(1m2+1n2)+η4m2n2)−1/2]

Any other point below or beside a rectangle follows from four corner rectangles with signs, as with Boussinesq; for a point off the axis of a circle the module integrates the point load over the circle about the point. The Boussinesq circle is on the page stress below a circular load.

4Westergaard against BoussinesqPoint load, circle and square, μs = 0.

Table 1. Point load: influence factors against r/z
r/zIB BoussinesqIW μs = 0IW μs = 0.2IW/IB (μs = 0)
00.47750.31830.42440.67
0.10.46570.30900.40800.66
0.20.43290.28360.36460.66
0.30.38490.24830.30740.65
0.40.32950.20990.24910.64
0.50.27330.17330.19720.63
0.60.22140.14110.15470.64
0.80.13860.09250.09530.67
10.08440.06130.06040.73
1.250.04540.03800.03610.84
1.50.02510.02470.02290.98
1.750.01440.01670.01531.17
20.00850.01180.01071.38
2.50.00340.00640.00571.90
30.00150.00380.00342.55

Δσz = (P/z²)·I. The two are equal at r/z = 1.52 for μs = 0. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its point load modules use.

Table 2. Below the centre of a uniformly loaded circle: Δσz/q against z/R
z/RBoussinesqWestergaard μs = 0ratio
0.250.9860.8260.84
0.50.9110.6670.73
0.750.7840.5310.68
10.6460.4230.65
1.50.4240.2720.64
20.2840.1840.65
30.1460.0950.65
40.0870.0570.66
50.0570.0380.66

Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its circular load and Westergaard modules use.

Table 3. Below the corner of a uniformly loaded square, m = n
m = nI3 BoussinesqIWc Westergaard μs = 0ratio
0.250.02700.01770.66
0.50.08400.05410.64
0.750.13720.08880.65
10.17520.11610.66
1.50.21570.15250.71
20.23250.17430.75
30.24390.19810.81
50.24860.21840.88
100.24980.23410.94

Δσz = q·I at the corner. For a very large area both tend to 0.25. Values computed by GeoTerva.

5When to use whichHomogeneous soil or layered soil.

  • Boussinesq for soils that are, at the scale of the foundation, homogeneous and free to strain sideways: sands, gravels, uniform clays and silts. It is the usual basis of stress increases for settlement in most foundation work.
  • Westergaard for deposits in which closely spaced, stiffer horizontal layers restrain lateral strain: varved or laminated clays, alternating thin layers of soft clay and denser silt or sand, a soft soil with closely spaced horizontal reinforcement. μs = 0 is the usual choice.
  • When the stratification is uncertain, computing both brackets the answer: Westergaard (μs = 0) gives the lower stress below a loaded area and, at shallow depth, the higher stress some distance beside it, which matters for the effect of a new load on a neighbouring structure.

6Worked exampleA raft on laminated clay.

A raft B × L = 4 m × 6 m applies q = 140 kPa to a laminated clay. Find Δσz below its centre at z = 3 m by both methods, with μs = 0 for Westergaard.

The raft is split into four rectangles of 2 m × 3 m meeting at the centre: m = 2/3 = 0.667, n = 3/3 = 1.000.

  • Boussinesq: I3 = 0.1451, Δσz = 4 × 140 × 0.1451 = 81.2 kPa.
  • Westergaard: η = 0.7071, IWc = 0.0946, Δσz = 4 × 140 × 0.0946 = 53.0 kPa, 65 % of the Boussinesq value.

At a point 3 m outside the middle of a long side and 1.5 m deep the order is reversed: Boussinesq gives 1.95 kPa and Westergaard 4.70 kPa. With depth the stresses below the centre fall, while beside the raft they first rise and then fall; the two profiles are:

Table 4. The worked example: Δσz (kPa) below the centre and 3 m outside a long side
z (m)centre, Boussinesqcentre, Westergaardoutside, Boussinesqoutside, Westergaard
1.5122.287.72.04.7
381.253.07.47.5
634.322.211.67.9
917.511.49.66.2
1210.46.87.24.6

q = 140 kPa, raft 4 m × 6 m, μs = 0. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its rectangle and Westergaard modules use.

7QuestionsShort answers.

Why is the Westergaard stress lower below the load?

With μs = 0, the usual choice, the rigid horizontal sheets prevent the soil from straining sideways, so the load is carried out to a wider area. Both solutions carry the whole load through every horizontal plane; Westergaard’s puts less of it below the load and more far from it.

Which Poisson’s ratio should be used with Westergaard’s solution?

μs = 0 is the usual choice; it gives the widest spread of the load and the lowest stress below it. Larger values concentrate the stress below the load (Table 1), and the solution breaks down at μs = 0.5.

Is the difference between the two methods large?

Below a loaded area, yes: for the centre of a circle at z = R, Westergaard (μs = 0) gives 0.423q against 0.646q by Boussinesq. Directly below a point load the ratio is 2/3 at every depth (1/π against 3/2π); far to the side Westergaard’s stress is the larger.

The theory behind it