GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Retaining walls

Retaining wall stability checks: sliding, overturning, eccentricity, bearing

The four checks of the external stability of a gravity or cantilever retaining wall, the factors of safety they are usually held to, and two walls checked step by step with every force and moment in a table.

  • Free to read
  • 4 checks
  • Gravity and cantilever
  • Worked example

1The free bodyThe wall, the soil it carries, and the forces on them.

A gravity or cantilever wall holds the backfill by its own weight and by the weight of the soil standing on its base. The free body for the stability checks is the wall together with that soil, cut along the underside of the base and along a vertical plane through the back edge of the base (the heel). The plane lies in the soil, so no wall friction acts on it: the thrust is taken parallel to the backfill surface, inclined at the backfill slope β. Per metre of wall the forces are:

  • the weights W of the wall and of the soil between its back and the plane, at their centroids;
  • the active thrust Pa on the plane (Rankine with a sloping backfill, see Rankine sloping backfill; or Coulomb, which with δ′ = β on this plane gives the same coefficient), and the thrust of a surcharge;
  • water pressures and uplift where there is water, the inertia forces and the seismic thrust under an earthquake (see the Mononobe–Okabe coefficient);
  • the reaction of the foundation: a normal force N and a shear force along the base, and the passive resistance of the soil in front of the toe.

Moments are taken about the toe, the front bottom corner of the base. A surcharge standing on the soil behind the wall pushes on the plane, but its weight is a favourable load that may be absent when the thrust acts, so it is usually left out of the resisting forces.

2SlidingBase friction against the horizontal push.

The base resists sliding by friction on the foundation, μN with μ = tan δb, plus any passive resistance Pp of the soil in front of the toe:

FSs=μN+PpΣHd,N=ΣV

N is the sum of the vertical forces, including the vertical component of an inclined thrust and less any uplift; ΣHd is the sum of the horizontal driving forces. For concrete or masonry cast directly on the foundation soil δb is commonly taken between about ⅔φ′ and φ′ of that soil, and lower for a smooth or precast base. On a clay foundation an adhesion term caB is added in the short term. The passive resistance needs a movement the wall may not make and soil that may be dug away: it is often neglected, or only partly counted.

3OverturningMoments about the toe.

FSo=ΣMRΣMO

ΣMR collects the moments that hold the wall back — the weights, the vertical component of the thrust — and ΣMO those that turn it over the toe: the horizontal thrusts, uplift, horizontal inertia. The passive resistance in front is not counted. Because some designers subtract the moment of the vertical thrust component from ΣMO instead of adding it to ΣMR, FSo is not a unique number; the eccentricity check below, which uses the net moment, is the more robust measure of the same mechanism.

4Eccentricity and bearing pressureThe resultant in the middle third.

The resultant of all the forces cuts the base at xR from the toe, at an eccentricity e from the centre of a base of width B:

xR=ΣMR−ΣMOΣV,e=B2−xR

For a rigid base with a linear contact pressure, the pressures under the toe and the heel are

qmax,min=ΣVB(1±6eB)

The heel stays in compression while e ≤ B/6, the resultant inside the middle third of the base. Beyond it the heel lifts off and a triangular pressure over a length 3xR carries the load:

qmax=2ΣV3xR

qmax is compared with the allowable bearing pressure. For an eccentric, inclined load, the ultimate bearing capacity is found on the effective width B′ = B − 2e (Meyerhof, 1953) with load-inclination factors (see shape, depth and inclination factors) and divided by its factor of safety. A deep-seated slip surface passing under the wall is a separate check, made by a slope stability analysis.

5Factors of safetyThe values usually required.

Table 1. The four checks and the values commonly required in allowable-stress design
CheckConditionUsual requirement (static)
SlidingFSs = (μN + Pp)/ΣHdFSs ≥ 1.5
OverturningFSo = ΣMR/ΣMO, about the toeFSo ≥ 2.0
Eccentricitye = B/2 − xR|e| ≤ B/6 on soil (no tension under the base)
Bearingqmax = ΣV/B·(1 + 6e/B)qmax ≤ qall, with a factor of about 3 on the ultimate bearing capacity

Under an earthquake the same checks are made with the seismic thrust and the inertia of the wall, usually against lower factors; the GeoTerva wall modules start with 1.5 (sliding) and 2.0 (overturning) static, 1.1 and 1.1 seismic, and every value can be changed. The governing code decides: limit-state codes apply partial factors to the actions and the resistances instead of one global factor.

6Worked example: a gravity wallPlain concrete, sloping backfill.

A plain concrete gravity wall (γc = 24 kN/m³) is 4.0 m high from the underside of its base. Its body is 0.6 m wide at the top, battered 0.4 m at the front and 0.8 m at the back, and stands on a footing 0.6 m thick projecting 0.4 m at the toe and the heel: B = 2.60 m, cross-section 5.640 m². The granular backfill (φ′ = 34°, γ = 19 kN/m³, dry) rises at β = 10° from the top of the wall; the base rests on a soil with μ = 0.50 and an allowable bearing pressure of 250 kPa. The ground in front is level with the top of the footing, and its passive resistance is neglected.

  • Thrust: the plane through the heel is h = 4.212 m high (the wall plus the rise of the slope over the heel). Rankine’s coefficient for φ′ = 34° and β = 10° is Ka = 0.294, so Pa = ½ × 0.294 × 19 × 4.212² = 49.60 kN/m, parallel to the slope at h/3 = 1.404 m: Ph = 48.85, Pv = 8.61 kN/m.
Table 2. Gravity wall: forces and moments about the toe, per metre of wall
ForceHorizontal (kN/m)Vertical (kN/m)Arm x from the toe (m)Height z above the base (m)Resisting moment (kN·m/m)Overturning moment (kN·m/m)
Wall, self-weight135.361.240167.81
Soil moving with the wall (behind the body, to the plane at the heel)54.092.168117.28
Active thrust of the soil, vertical part8.612.60022.40
Active thrust of the soil, horizontal part48.851.40468.58
Total48.85198.07307.4868.58

Moments: resisting = weight × arm, overturning = horizontal force × height. Computed by the engine of the GeoTerva gravity wall module.

  • Sliding: FSs = 0.50 × 198.07 / 48.85 = 2.03 ≥ 1.5 — OK.
  • Overturning: FSo = 307.48 / 68.58 = 4.48 ≥ 2.0 — OK.
  • Eccentricity: xR = (307.48 − 68.58) / 198.07 = 1.206 m, e = 1.30 − 1.206 = 0.094 m ≤ B/6 = 0.433 m — OK.
  • Bearing: qmax = 198.07 / 2.60 × (1 + 6 × 0.094 / 2.60) = 92.7 kPa under the toe, qmin = 59.7 kPa under the heel; 92.7 ≤ 250 kPa — OK.

The wall is far from overturning; sliding is its governing check. The gravity wall module of GeoTerva adds water on both sides, uplift, a surcharge, part of the passive resistance in front and the earthquake, and prints the same table for each load case.

7A cantilever wallLevel backfill with a surcharge.

A reinforced-concrete cantilever wall has a stem 5.0 m high, 0.30 m thick at the top and 0.50 m at the bottom (vertical back), on a base slab 0.60 m thick with a toe of 1.0 m and a heel of 2.6 m: B = 4.10 m, total height 5.60 m. The level backfill (φ′ = 32°, γ = 18.5 kN/m³, dry) carries a surcharge q = 10 kPa; 0.6 m of fill lies over the toe; μ = 0.50, qall = 250 kPa; passive resistance neglected.

With Ka = 0.307 on the plane through the heel (h = 5.60 m), the soil gives ½ × 0.307 × 18.5 × 5.60² at h/3 and the surcharge Kaqh = 0.307 × 10 × 5.60 at h/2. The weight of the surcharge over the heel (26.00 kN/m) is left out of the resisting forces.

Table 3. Cantilever wall: forces and moments about the toe, per metre of wall
ForceHorizontal (kN/m)Vertical (kN/m)Arm x from the toe (m)Height z above the base (m)Resisting moment (kN·m/m)Overturning moment (kN·m/m)
Wall, self-weight107.041.712183.23
Soil moving with the wall (behind the body, to the plane at the heel)240.502.800673.40
Fill over the toe11.230.5065.68
Active thrust of the soil89.131.867166.38
Active thrust of the surcharge17.212.80048.18
Total106.34358.77862.32214.55

Computed by the engine of the GeoTerva cantilever retaining wall module.

  • Sliding: FSs = 0.50 × 358.77 / 106.34 = 1.69 ≥ 1.5 — OK.
  • Overturning: FSo = 862.32 / 214.55 = 4.02 ≥ 2.0 — OK.
  • Eccentricity: xR = 1.805 m, e = 0.245 m ≤ B/6 = 0.683 m — OK.
  • Bearing: qmax = 118.8 kPa, qmin = 56.2 kPa — OK.

The long heel puts most of the resisting weight in the soil it carries. Sliding is again the narrow check: a shear key under the base, a longer heel, or crediting part of the passive resistance in front are the usual remedies. The cantilever retaining wall module also designs the stem, the toe and the heel as reinforced-concrete members.

8QuestionsShort answers.

Why is the earth pressure taken on a vertical plane through the heel?

Because the soil standing on the heel moves with the wall. The failure in the backfill starts from the back edge of the base, so the free body is the wall plus that soil, and the thrust acts on the vertical plane through the heel — soil against soil, without wall friction, parallel to the backfill surface.

Should the passive resistance in front of the toe be counted against sliding?

Only with care. It needs a movement larger than the wall may be allowed to make, and the soil in front may be excavated, eroded or softened. It is often neglected, or only a part of it is counted; it is never counted in overturning or bearing.

What if the resultant falls outside the middle third of the base?

The heel lifts off the foundation and the contact pressure becomes a triangle of length 3xR, with qmax = 2ΣV/(3xR). On soil this is usually not accepted for permanent loads: the base is widened, or the heel lengthened, until e ≤ B/6.

The theory behind it