GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Pile groups

Pile group settlement: the equivalent footing and Vesic’s rule

Why a group of piles settles more than one pile, and by how much: the consolidation of the clay below the group by the equivalent footing at two thirds of the pile length, and the elastic settlement of the group from that of one pile.

  • Free to read
  • 2L/3 and 2:1
  • √(Bg/D)
  • Worked example

1Two parts of the settlementImmediate, and by consolidation.

A group of piles settles more than a single pile carrying the same load per pile. The load of every pile spreads into the ground, and below the group these zones overlap: the stressed zone has the width of the group, not of one pile, and it reaches layers far below the tips. The GeoTerva pile group module works the settlement out in two parts and adds them:

S=Sg(e)+Sc

Sg(e) is the elastic settlement of the group, which occurs as the load is applied and is the main part in sand; Sc is the consolidation settlement of the clay layers below the group, which develops over months or years as the clay drains (see the time factor) and is usually the larger part in clay.

2Consolidation: the equivalent footing at 2L/3The load at two thirds of the length, spread 2:1.

Terzaghi and Peck (1967) replaced a group of friction piles by an equivalent footing: a footing of the plan size of the group, Lg × Bg to the outside of the outer piles, placed at two thirds of the pile length below the top of the piles, since the piles have passed part of their load to the soil above that level. Below it the load Qg spreads at 2 vertical to 1 horizontal, so at a depth z below the equivalent footing the vertical stress it adds is

Δσ′=Qg(Bg+z)(Lg+z),z0=zc+2L3

zc is the depth of the base of the cap and z0 that of the equivalent footing. The module takes Δσ′ at the middle of every clay layer, or of the part of it below z0; a clay above z0 is not loaded by this method. Each layer of thickness H then settles by one-dimensional consolidation from its effective stress σ′o. For a normally consolidated clay

ΔS=CcH1+e0log⁡σo′+Δσ′σo′

and for an over-consolidated clay, with σ′c = OCR·σ′o and the recompression index Cs (Cc/5 when none is given),

ΔS=CsH1+e0log⁡σo′+Δσ′σo′if σo′+Δσ′≤σc′
ΔS=CsH1+e0log⁡σc′σo′+CcH1+e0log⁡σo′+Δσ′σc′if σo′+Δσ′>σc′

Sc = ΣΔS over the layers. The module takes Qg as the vertical load on the cap, V, and 2L/3 of the whole embedded length. Where piles pass through a soft layer into a firmer one, practice often places the equivalent footing at two thirds of the embedment in the firmer layer, and for end-bearing piles at their tips; such a case is entered with the ground the piles actually bear in.

3Elastic settlement: Vesic’s ruleThe group settles √(Bg/D) times one pile.

From load tests on instrumented groups of piles in sand, Vesic (1969) related the elastic settlement of a group to that of a single pile under the same load per pile by the ratio of their widths:

Sg(e)=BgDse

Bg is the width of the group and D that of one pile. se is the elastic settlement of one pile at its working load Qw = V/n, the sum of the shortening of the pile and the settlements caused by its point load and its shaft load (Vesic, 1977), worked out on elastic settlement of a pile. The factor depends only on the layout and on s/D:

Table 1. Vesic’s group factor √(Bg/D) for square groups n × n
Groups/D = 2.5: Bg/Ds/D = 2.5: √(Bg/D)s/D = 3: Bg/Ds/D = 3: √(Bg/D)s/D = 4: Bg/Ds/D = 4: √(Bg/D)
2 × 23.51.8714.02.0005.02.236
3 × 36.02.4497.02.6469.03.000
4 × 48.52.91510.03.16213.03.606
5 × 511.03.31713.03.60617.04.123
6 × 613.53.67416.04.00021.04.583
8 × 818.54.30122.04.69029.05.385
10 × 1023.54.84828.05.29237.06.083

Bg = (n − 1)s + D. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile group module uses.

A 2 × 2 group at 2.5D settles 1.87 times as much as one of its piles, a 10 × 10 group at 4D 6.08 times. The rule comes from tests in sand; in clay the consolidation settlement of the previous section is usually the larger part.

4Worked exampleTwenty bored piles over clay layers.

A cap on twenty bored concrete piles, D = 0.60 m and L = 18 m, in 4 rows of 5 at s = 1.80 m (3D), carries V = 4500 kN, the weight of the cap included. The group is Bg × Lg = 6.00 m × 7.80 m. The ground, with the water table at 1.5 m:

  • 0–3 m fill, sand, φ′ = 30°, γ = 18/19.5 kN/m³;
  • 3–10 m soft clay, cu = 35 kPa, γ = 17.5 kN/m³, e0 = 1.10, Cc = 0.40, normally consolidated;
  • 10–22 m firm clay, cu = 70 kPa, γ = 18.5 kN/m³, e0 = 0.80, Cc = 0.24, OCR = 2, entered as two layers, 10–17 m and 17–22 m;
  • 22–32 m silty clay, γ = 18 kN/m³, e0 = 0.90, Cc = 0.30, normally consolidated, entered as two layers of 5 m;
  • below 32 m dense sand, φ′ = 38°.

For the elastic part Es = 25 MPa and μs = 0.3 below the pile base, Ep = 30000 MPa, ξ = 0.6. One pile alone carries Qu = 997 kN (Qs = 819 kN, Qp = 178 kN) and the group Qg(u) = 13658 kN, 3.04 times V.

  • The equivalent footing is at z0 = 2 × 18/3 = 12.0 m. The soft clay, 3–10 m, lies above it and is not loaded by the method; the upper firm-clay layer counts from 12.0 m.
  • Firm clay 1, 12.0–17.0 m: H = 5.00 m, z = 2.50 m, Δσ′ = 4500/((6.00 + 2.50)(7.80 + 2.50)) = 51.40 kPa; σ′o = 134.5 kPa and σ′c = 2 × 134.5 = 268.9 kPa, so the clay stays below its preconsolidation stress: ΔS = 0.048 × 5/1.80 × log(185.9/134.5) = 18.7 mm.
  • Silty clay 1, 22.0–27.0 m: z = 12.50 m, Δσ′ = 4500/((6.00 + 12.50)(7.80 + 12.50)) = 11.98 kPa, σ′o = 220.1 kPa, normally consolidated: ΔS = 0.30 × 5/1.90 × log(232.1/220.1) = 18.2 mm.
Table 2. Consolidation settlement of the worked group, clay layer by clay layer
LayerPart below z0H (m)z (m)Δσ′ (kPa)σ′o (kPa)σ′c (kPa)IndexΔS (mm)
Firm clay 112.0–17.0 m5.002.5051.4134.5268.9Cs18.7
Firm clay 217.0–22.0 m5.007.5021.8177.9355.8Cs6.7
Silty clay 122.0–27.0 m5.0012.5012.0220.1220.1Cc18.2
Silty clay 227.0–32.0 m5.0017.507.6261.1261.1Cc9.8
Total53.4

Cs = Cc/5 in the firm clay. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile group module uses.

  • Elastic. Qw = 4500/20 = 225.0 kN, shared between the shaft and the base in the proportion of their ultimate resistances (82 % to the shaft): Qws = 184.8 kN, Qwp = 40.2 kN. Vesic’s three parts give se1 = 0.32 mm, se2 = 2.64 mm and se3 = 0.47 mm, se = 3.43 mm; Sg(e) = √(6.00/0.60) × 3.43 = 3.162 × 3.43 = 10.8 mm.
  • Total: S = 10.8 + 53.4 = 64.2 mm, of which the consolidation of the clay is 83 %.

The module takes one stress for each layer, at its middle, while the stress of the group falls with depth. Entered as one firm-clay layer and one silty-clay layer, the same ground would give Sc = 47.8 mm; in layers of 2.5 m it gives 55.2 mm, against the 53.4 mm of layers of 5 m. A thick clay layer is therefore better entered as several thinner ones, each with its own e0 and Cc. A normally consolidated clay settles even under a small added stress: the silty clay, which takes only 12.0 and 7.6 kPa, gives 28.0 of the 53.4 mm.

5Spacing, width and settlementA wider group: less consolidation, more elastic settlement.

The same twenty piles spaced further apart make a wider equivalent footing: the stress it adds in the clay falls, and the consolidation settlement with it, while Vesic’s factor √(Bg/D) grows. Table 3 gives both for the worked group.

Table 3. Settlement of the worked group (4 × 5 bored piles, V = 4500 kN) against the spacing
s/Ds (m)Bg × Lg (m)Δσ′ in the upper firm clay (kPa)Sc (mm)√(Bg/D)Sg(e) (mm)S (mm)
2.51.505.10 × 6.6065.161.52.91510.071.5
3.01.806.00 × 7.8051.453.43.16210.864.2
3.52.106.90 × 9.0041.646.93.39111.658.5
4.02.407.80 × 10.2034.441.63.60612.453.9
5.03.009.60 × 12.6024.633.44.00013.747.1

The single pile, and so se = 3.43 mm, is the same in every row. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile group module uses.

From s = 2.5D to 5D the consolidation settlement falls from 61.5 to 33.4 mm and the elastic settlement rises from 10.0 to 13.7 mm.

6QuestionsShort answers.

Why is the equivalent footing placed at 2L/3?

Friction piles pass their load to the soil gradually along the shaft; placing the whole load at two thirds of the length, on a footing of the size of the group, is the simplification of Terzaghi and Peck (1967) for that transfer. Below it the load is spread at 2 vertical to 1 horizontal.

How much more does a pile group settle than a single pile?

Under the same load per pile, its elastic settlement is √(Bg/D) times that of one pile (Vesic, 1969): from 1.87 for a 2 × 2 group at 2.5D to 6.08 for a 10 × 10 group at 4D. The consolidation of clay below the tips comes in addition.

Are the elastic and the consolidation settlements added?

Yes: the GeoTerva pile group module gives S = Sg(e) + Sc. The elastic part occurs as the load is applied, the consolidation part over time; Sc is the settlement at the end of consolidation.

The theory behind it