GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Pile groups

p-multipliers of a pile group: the lateral load, row by row

Why the rows of a pile group pushed sideways do not carry the same load: the p-multipliers of the leading, second, third and trailing rows against the spacing, for sand and for clay, and the group solved under a rigid cap.

  • Free to read
  • s/D = 2.5–8
  • Sand · clay
  • Worked example

1What a p-multiplier isThe p–y curve of a pile in a group, lowered by its row.

A single pile under a lateral load pushes on undisturbed soil, and the reaction of that soil at each depth follows its p–y curve (see p–y curves for sand and clay). In a group the piles stand one behind another in the direction of the load. A pile in the second row pushes on soil that the pile in front of it has already stressed and moved away, so it meets less resistance at the same deflection; the rows further back are in the lee of two or more rows. This is called shadowing.

Full-scale tests on a group of piles in sand (Brown, Morrison and Reese, 1988) showed that the p–y curve of a pile in a group keeps its shape but is lowered by a factor, the p-multiplier Pm:

pgroup(y,z)=Pm·psingle(y,z),Pm≤1

Pm scales the whole curve: its initial slope and its ultimate resistance alike, at the same deflection y and depth z. It depends on the row of the pile (the leading row, the second, the third and those behind it) and on the spacing s of the rows in the direction of the load, measured in pile widths D. Later full-scale and centrifuge tests (McVay et al., 1995; Rollins et al., 2006) gave values for other spacings and soils. The leading row keeps most of its resistance, the rows behind it lose more, and all rows approach 1 as the spacing grows.

2Clay: Rollins et al. (2006)Three logarithmic equations of the spacing.

From full-scale lateral load tests of pile groups in cohesive soil at spacings of 3.3 to 5.65 diameters, Rollins and co-workers (2006) fitted the multipliers of the first three rows to the logarithm of the spacing:

Pm1=0.26ln⁡(s/D)+0.5
Pm2=0.52ln⁡(s/D)
Pm3=0.60ln⁡(s/D)−0.25(third row and those behind it)

None of them is taken above 1. The GeoTerva pile group module uses these equations for every clay layer, keeps them above 0.05, and carries them on outside the tested range of spacings, which it flags when the spacing is closer than the tests.

3Sand: AASHTO LRFDThe multipliers at 3D and 5D, and between them.

AASHTO LRFD gives the multipliers of a group at two spacings in the direction of the load, from the tests of Brown, Morrison and Reese (1988) and the centrifuge tests of McVay et al. (1995):

  • s = 3D: leading row 0.80, second row 0.40, third row and beyond 0.30;
  • s = 5D: leading row 1.00, second row 0.85, third row and beyond 0.70.

Between the two spacings the values are interpolated linearly:

Pm(s)=Pm(3D)+s/D−32[Pm(5D)−Pm(3D)](3≤s/D≤5)

The GeoTerva module takes these multipliers for a sand layer. Beyond 5D it goes on linearly to 1.0 at 8D, where the group effect has gone; closer than 3D it holds the values of 3D. A pile crossing clay and sand takes, layer by layer, the multiplier of its row for the soil of that layer.

4Tables of PmBy row and spacing, and the mean of the rows of a group.

Table 1. p-multipliers by row against the spacing s/D in the direction of the load
s/DClay: row 1Clay: row 2Clay: row 3+Sand: row 1Sand: row 2Sand: row 3+
2.50.740.480.300.800.400.30
3.00.790.570.410.800.400.30
3.50.830.650.500.850.510.40
4.00.860.720.580.900.630.50
4.50.890.780.650.950.740.60
5.00.920.840.721.000.850.70
6.00.970.930.831.000.900.80
7.01.001.000.921.000.950.90
8.01.001.001.001.001.001.00

Clay: Rollins et al. (2006), not above 1 and not below 0.05; their tests covered 3.3 to 5.65 diameters. Sand: AASHTO LRFD at 3D and 5D, linear between, the 3D values below 3D and a linear rise to 1.0 at 8D. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its pile group module uses.

When the lateral load reverses (wind, waves, an earthquake), every row is at times the leading row and at times in the lee. The module then gives every row the mean of the multipliers of the rows of the group:

Table 2. Mean p-multiplier of the rows of a group, for a load that reverses
GroupClay, s = 3DClay, s = 4DClay, s = 5DSand, s = 3DSand, s = 4DSand, s = 5D
2 rows0.680.790.880.600.760.93
3 rows0.590.720.820.500.670.85
4 rows0.540.690.800.450.630.81
5 rows0.520.670.780.420.600.79
6 rows0.500.650.770.400.590.78

The mean over the rows of Table 1 (row 1, row 2, then row 3+ for every further row). Values computed by GeoTerva.

5The group under a rigid capOne deflection, rows of unequal load.

A rigid cap moves the heads of all its piles by the same deflection Δ. Since the rows have different p–y curves, they carry different loads at that deflection, and the deflection of the cap is the one at which the loads of the rows add up to the lateral load H on the cap:

∑knkHk(Δ)=H

nk is the number of piles in row k and Hk(Δ) the load one of its piles takes when its head is held at Δ: the laterally loaded pile on the p–y curves of its layers, each scaled by the multiplier of the row. The GeoTerva module builds the load–deflection curve of each kind of row by holding the head at a series of deflections, finds Δ where their sum reaches H, and solves every row again at that Δ. The group efficiency under lateral load compares the mean load of a pile of the group with the load a single pile takes at the same deflection:

ηL=H/nHsingle(Δ)

It is not the efficiency of the axial capacity (see pile group efficiency), which concerns the ultimate vertical load of friction piles.

6Worked exampleTwelve piles in four rows, clay over sand.

A cap stands on 12 bored concrete piles in 4 rows of 3, D = 0.75 m, L = 18 m, E = 30 000 MPa, so EI = 30 × 10⁶ × π × 0.75⁴ / 64 = 465947 kN·m². The rows are s = 3.00 m apart in the direction of the load (s/D = 4.0), and the cap holds the heads against rotation. The ground is 5 m of clay with cu = 60 kPa over a sand with φ′ = 35°; the water table is 2 m down. The cap carries H = 2400 kN, static, with no axial load counted in the lateral analysis.

  • Multipliers (Table 1, s/D = 4.0): in the clay 0.86, 0.72 and 0.58; in the sand 0.90, 0.63 and 0.50 for the leading, second, and third and fourth rows.
  • One pile alone under the equal share H/n = 200 kN deflects 3.23 mm.
  • The group: the cap deflects Δ = 5.17 mm, 1.60 times the single pile. A pile of the leading row takes 234.4 kN, of the second row 206.8 kN, of the third and the fourth 179.4 kN each: 3 × (234.4 + 206.8 + 179.4 + 179.4) = 2400 kN.
  • Efficiency under lateral load: a single pile would take 259.1 kN at Δ = 5.17 mm, so ηL = 200 / 259.1 = 0.77.
  • Moments: the largest bending moment, at the head held by the cap, is 465 kN·m in a pile of the leading row and 391 kN·m in one of the trailing row: the leading row is the one to design for.

Were the load to reverse, every row would take the mean multiplier (0.69 in the clay, 0.63 in the sand, Table 2) and the cap would deflect 5.14 mm, each pile carrying 200 kN. The same group with its rows closer together or further apart:

Table 3. The worked group (H = 2400 kN) at other spacings of the rows
s/Ds (m)Pm sand, rows 1 / 2 / 3+Pm clay, rows 1 / 2 / 3+Δ (mm)Leading pile (kN)Trailing pile (kN)ηL
3.02.250.80 / 0.40 / 0.300.79 / 0.57 / 0.416.76258.6167.60.66
4.03.000.90 / 0.63 / 0.500.86 / 0.72 / 0.585.17234.4179.40.77
5.03.751.00 / 0.85 / 0.700.92 / 0.84 / 0.724.30221.0186.00.86
6.04.501.00 / 0.90 / 0.800.97 / 0.93 / 0.833.77212.5190.20.92

Δ: the deflection of the cap; leading and trailing pile: the lateral load on one pile of the first and of the last row; ηL: the mean pile load over the load of a single pile at Δ. Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its pile group module.

Widening the rows from 3D to 6D lowers the deflection of the cap from 6.76 to 3.77 mm and evens out the loads of the rows, as the multipliers rise towards 1. The bending moment and the deflection along each pile follow from the same analysis (see deflection and bending moment of a laterally loaded pile).

7QuestionsShort answers.

What is a p-multiplier?

A factor Pm ≤ 1 by which the p–y curve of a single pile is multiplied to represent a pile in a group. It accounts for the shadowing of the rows behind the leading row and depends on the row and on the spacing in the direction of the load. Brown, Morrison and Reese (1988) introduced it from full-scale tests on a pile group in sand.

Which p-multiplier should be used when the lateral load reverses?

Under wind, waves or an earthquake each row is in turn the leading row and a trailing row. A common practice, and the one of the GeoTerva module, is to give every row the mean of the multipliers of the rows of the group (Table 2): for 4 rows at s = 4D, 0.63 in sand and 0.69 in clay.

Is the p-multiplier the same as the group efficiency?

No. The p-multiplier scales the soil reaction of a row; the efficiency of the group under lateral load ηL follows from the analysis of all the rows together, as the mean load of a pile of the group over the load of a single pile at the same deflection. The group efficiency of the axial capacity (Converse–Labarre and others) is a different quantity again.

The theory behind it