GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Piles

Meyerhof pile point bearing in sand: Nq* and the limiting value

The unit point resistance of a pile in sand by Meyerhof (1976): the bearing capacity factor Nq* for every friction angle from 20° to 45°, the limiting value ql, and the effective stress at which that limit takes over.

  • Free to read
  • φ′ = 20–45°
  • Limiting value ql
  • Worked example

1The point resistance of a pile in sandqp = q′Nq* under the tip.

A pile carries its load partly on its tip and partly along its shaft: Qu = Qp + Qs. Under the tip the sand fails in bearing, as under a footing, but deep in the ground. For a sand (c′ = 0) only the surcharge term of the bearing-capacity equation remains, and Meyerhof (1976) writes the point resistance as

Qp=Apqp=Apq′Nq*

where Ap is the area of the pile section, q′ the effective vertical stress at the level of the tip and Nq* a bearing capacity factor of the deep foundation, which depends on the friction angle φ′ of the sand at the tip. Meyerhof’s Nq* are the maximum values, reached once the tip is embedded deep enough in the bearing stratum.

Nq* is far larger than the Nq of a shallow footing at the same angle: at φ′ = 35° it is 143.0 against 33.3 (see bearing capacity factors). Below a deep tip the slip surfaces close on the soil around the shaft instead of rising to the ground surface, and the factor grows accordingly.

2The limiting valueql = 0.5 pa Nq* tan φ′.

Measured point resistance does not grow without bound with depth. Meyerhof therefore caps the unit point resistance at a limiting value that depends on the friction angle alone:

qp=q′Nq*≤ql,ql=0.5paNq*tan⁡φ′

pa is the atmospheric pressure, 100 kPa (about 2000 lb/ft²). The cap is on the stress, not on a depth. Dividing ql by Nq* shows when it governs: the limit takes over as soon as the effective stress at the tip exceeds

q′=0.5patan⁡φ′

which is 28.9 kPa at φ′ = 30° and 42.0 kPa at φ′ = 40°. In a dry sand of γ = 18 kN/m³ these stresses are reached at depths of only 1.60 m and 2.33 m. For practically every pile in a homogeneous sand, then, Meyerhof’s unit point resistance is the limiting value ql itself, and a longer pile gains skin friction rather than point resistance.

In Meyerhof’s description qp grows with the embedment Lb of the tip in the bearing stratum up to a critical ratio (Lb/D)cr and is constant at ql beyond it. In a homogeneous sand Lb is the embedded length L. The GeoTerva pile modules take it so, apply the limit as written above and report which of the two, q′Nq* or ql, governs.

3Table of Nq*, φ′ = 20–45°Every degree, with the limiting value.

Table 1. Meyerhof’s Nq*, the limiting point resistance ql and the stress at which it governs
φ′ (°)Nq* (Meyerhof)ql (kPa)q′ above which ql governs (kPa)Nq of a shallow footing
2012.422618.26.4
2113.826519.27.1
2215.531320.27.8
2317.938021.28.7
2421.447622.39.6
2526.060623.310.7
2629.571924.411.9
2734.086625.513.2
2839.7105526.614.7
2946.5128927.716.4
3056.7163728.918.4
3168.2204930.020.6
3281.0253131.223.2
3396.0311732.526.1
34115.0387833.729.4
35143.0500635.033.3
36168.0610336.337.8
37194.0730937.742.9
38231.0902439.148.9
39276.01117540.556.0
40346.01451642.064.2
41420.01825543.573.9
42525.02363645.085.4
43650.03030746.699.0
44780.03766248.3115.3
45930.04650050.0134.9

Nq* after Meyerhof (1976), degree by degree; between whole degrees the GeoTerva pile modules interpolate linearly (at φ′ = 33.5°, Nq* = 105.5). ql = 0.5paNq*tanφ′ with pa = 100 kPa. The last column is Reissner’s Nq of the general bearing-capacity equation, for comparison. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its modules use.

4Worked exampleA driven pile, 0.45 m in diameter, 13.5 m long.

A driven concrete pile of circular section, D = 0.45 m, is embedded L = 13.5 m in a sand with φ′ = 34°, γ = 18 kN/m³ above the water table at 3.0 m depth and γsat = 20 kN/m³ below it (γw = 9.81 kN/m³). Ap = πD²/4 = 0.1590 m².

  • Effective stress at the tip: q′ = 18 × 3.0 + (20 − 9.81) × 10.5 = 161.0 kPa.
  • Factor: Table 1 gives Nq* = 115.0 at φ′ = 34°, so q′Nq* = 161.0 × 115.0 = 18514 kPa.
  • Limit: ql = 0.5 × 100 × 115.0 × tan 34° = 3878 kPa, smaller than q′Nq*, so it governs: qp = 3878 kPa.
  • Point resistance: Qp = Apqp = 0.1590 × 3878 = 617 kN.

Without the limit the tip would be credited with 2945 kN, 4.8 times as much. The limit is reached where q′ = 0.5 × 100 × tan 34° = 33.7 kPa, at a depth of 1.87 m in this profile.

The same pile gives Qp = 1003 kN by Vesic’s method (m = 250) and 1075 kN by Coyle and Castello’s; its shaft is worked out on pile skin friction in sand. The capacity Qu = Qp + Qs is then divided by one factor of safety, commonly 2.5 to 4 for a single pile.

5QuestionsShort answers.

Why is Nq* so much larger than the Nq of a footing?

Nq* describes the failure below a deep tip, where the slip surfaces close on the soil around the shaft instead of rising to the ground surface. At φ′ = 35° Meyerhof’s Nq* is 143.0, against 33.3 for a shallow footing.

Does the point resistance keep growing with the pile length?

Only until the limiting value is reached. q′Nq* exceeds ql = 0.5paNq*tanφ′ as soon as q′ is larger than 0.5patanφ′ (35.0 kPa at φ′ = 35°), which in a homogeneous sand happens within the first few metres. Below that, a longer pile gains skin friction, not point resistance.

How sensitive is the point resistance to φ′?

Very. Nq* rises from 56.7 at φ′ = 30° to 96.0 at 33° and 168.0 at 36°, and ql rises with it. The friction angle of the sand at and just below the tip deserves more care than any other input.

The theory behind it