1Point bearing from cavity expansionThe stiffness of the sand enters too.
Vesic (1977) treated the tip of a pile as a cavity expanding in the soil: the sand under and around the tip must be compressed before it fails, so its stiffness enters the point resistance as well as its strength. On effective-stress parameters, for a sand (c′ = 0),
where Ap is the area of the pile section and σ̄′o the mean effective normal stress at the level of the tip, not the vertical one:
q′ is the effective vertical stress at the tip and Ko the coefficient of earth pressure at rest. Written this way, Vesic’s equation has the form of Meyerhof’s with another factor,
so the two methods differ in what the factor is built from, not in the shape of the equation.
2The rigidity indexIr and Irr, from the stiffness of the sand.
Vesic’s factor depends on the friction angle and on the reduced rigidity index of the sand, which allows for the volume change of the sand in the plastic zone under the tip:
Es is the modulus of elasticity of the sand, μs its Poisson ratio, Gs its shear modulus and Δ the average volumetric strain in the plastic zone below the tip. For 25° ≤ φ′ ≤ 45° the approximations of Chen and Kulhawy (1994) give all three from φ′ (in degrees), q′ and a single stiffness number m:
pa is the atmospheric pressure (100 kPa). m is about 100 to 200 for a loose sand, 200 to 500 for a medium dense one and 500 to 1000 for a dense one. Because Ir falls as q′ grows, and Δ grows with q′, the reduced index falls with depth:
| q′ (kPa) \ m | 100 | 200 | 300 | 500 | 1000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 199.9 | 355.5 | 479.9 | 666.6 | 941.1 |
| 50 | 100.0 | 177.7 | 240.0 | 333.3 | 470.5 |
| 100 | 50.0 | 88.9 | 120.0 | 166.6 | 235.3 |
| 150 | 33.3 | 59.2 | 80.0 | 111.1 | 156.8 |
| 200 | 25.0 | 44.4 | 60.0 | 83.3 | 117.6 |
| 300 | 16.7 | 29.6 | 40.0 | 55.5 | 78.4 |
| 400 | 12.5 | 22.2 | 30.0 | 41.7 | 58.8 |
Irr = Ir/(1 + IrΔ) with the approximations above and pa = 100 kPa. Values above 500 lie beyond Vesic’s table of Nσ*; the GeoTerva modules then take its last column. Values computed by GeoTerva.
3Table of Nσ*, φ′ = 25–45°Against the reduced rigidity index.
Nσ* is read against φ′ and Irr. At the same friction angle a stiffer sand, with a larger Irr, carries a larger factor:
| φ′ (°) \ Irr | 10 | 20 | 40 | 60 | 80 | 100 | 200 | 300 | 400 | 500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 12.12 | 15.95 | 20.98 | 24.64 | 27.61 | 30.16 | 39.70 | 46.61 | 52.24 | 57.06 |
| 26 | 13.18 | 17.47 | 23.15 | 27.30 | 30.69 | 33.60 | 44.53 | 52.51 | 59.02 | 64.62 |
| 27 | 14.33 | 19.12 | 25.52 | 30.21 | 34.06 | 37.37 | 49.88 | 59.05 | 66.56 | 73.04 |
| 28 | 15.57 | 20.91 | 28.10 | 33.40 | 37.75 | 41.51 | 55.77 | 66.29 | 74.93 | 82.40 |
| 29 | 16.90 | 22.85 | 30.90 | 36.87 | 41.79 | 46.05 | 62.27 | 74.30 | 84.21 | 92.80 |
| 30 | 18.24 | 24.95 | 33.95 | 40.66 | 46.21 | 51.02 | 69.43 | 83.14 | 94.48 | 104.33 |
| 31 | 19.88 | 27.22 | 37.27 | 44.79 | 51.03 | 56.46 | 77.31 | 92.90 | 105.84 | 117.11 |
| 32 | 21.55 | 29.68 | 40.88 | 49.30 | 56.30 | 62.41 | 85.96 | 103.66 | 118.39 | 131.24 |
| 33 | 23.34 | 32.34 | 44.80 | 54.20 | 62.05 | 68.92 | 95.46 | 115.51 | 132.24 | 146.87 |
| 34 | 25.28 | 35.21 | 49.05 | 59.54 | 68.33 | 76.02 | 105.90 | 128.55 | 147.51 | 164.12 |
| 35 | 27.36 | 38.32 | 53.67 | 65.36 | 75.17 | 83.78 | 117.33 | 142.89 | 164.33 | 183.16 |
| 36 | 29.60 | 41.68 | 58.68 | 71.69 | 82.62 | 92.24 | 129.87 | 158.65 | 182.85 | 204.14 |
| 37 | 32.02 | 45.31 | 64.13 | 78.57 | 90.75 | 101.48 | 143.61 | 175.95 | 203.23 | 227.26 |
| 38 | 34.63 | 49.24 | 70.03 | 86.05 | 99.60 | 111.56 | 158.65 | 194.94 | 225.62 | 252.71 |
| 39 | 37.44 | 53.50 | 76.45 | 94.20 | 109.24 | 122.54 | 175.11 | 215.78 | 250.23 | 280.71 |
| 40 | 40.47 | 58.10 | 83.40 | 103.05 | 119.74 | 134.52 | 193.13 | 238.62 | 277.26 | 311.50 |
| 41 | 43.74 | 63.07 | 90.96 | 112.68 | 131.18 | 147.59 | 212.84 | 263.67 | 306.94 | 345.34 |
| 42 | 47.27 | 68.46 | 99.16 | 123.16 | 143.64 | 161.83 | 234.40 | 291.13 | 339.52 | 382.53 |
| 43 | 51.08 | 74.30 | 108.08 | 134.56 | 157.21 | 177.36 | 257.99 | 321.22 | 375.28 | 423.39 |
| 44 | 55.20 | 80.62 | 117.76 | 146.97 | 172.00 | 194.31 | 283.80 | 354.20 | 414.51 | 468.28 |
| 45 | 59.66 | 87.48 | 128.28 | 160.48 | 188.12 | 212.79 | 312.03 | 390.35 | 457.57 | 517.58 |
Nσ* after Vesic (1977), from the theory of the expansion of cavities. Between the rows and the columns the GeoTerva pile modules interpolate (linearly in φ′, in the logarithm of Irr), and outside the table they hold the value at its edge. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its modules use.
4Worked exampleA driven pile, 0.45 m in diameter, 13.5 m long.
A driven concrete pile of circular section, D = 0.45 m, is embedded L = 13.5 m in a medium dense sand with φ′ = 34° and m = 250, γ = 18 kN/m³ above the water table at 3.0 m depth and γsat = 20 kN/m³ below it. The effective vertical stress at the tip is q′ = 18 × 3.0 + (20 − 9.81) × 10.5 = 161.0 kPa, and Ap = 0.1590 m².
- Mean stress: Ko = 1 − sin 34° = 0.441, σ̄′o = (1 + 2 × 0.441)/3 × 161.0 = 101.0 kPa.
- Stiffness: Es = 250 × 100 = 25000 kPa, μs = 0.1 + 0.3 × (34 − 25)/20 = 0.235.
- Rigidity index: Ir = 25000 / (2 × 1.235 × 161.0 × tan 34°) = 93.2; Δ = 0.005 × (1 − 9/20) × 161.0/100 = 0.00443; Irr = 93.2 / (1 + 93.2 × 0.00443) = 66.0.
- Factor: between the columns Irr = 60 and 80 of Table 2, at φ′ = 34°, Nσ* = 62.44.
- Point resistance: qp = 101.0 × 62.44 = 6305 kPa, Qp = 0.1590 × 6305 = 1003 kN.
With m = 100 (a loose sand) the same pile gives Qp = 716 kN, with m = 500 (a dense one) 1235 kN. By Meyerhof’s method it gives 617 kN, where the limiting value governs, and by Coyle and Castello’s 1075 kN. The shaft of this pile is worked out on pile skin friction in sand.
5QuestionsShort answers.
What is the reduced rigidity index Irr?
The rigidity index Ir = Gs/(q′ tanφ′) compares the stiffness of the sand with its strength at the tip; Irr = Ir/(1 + IrΔ) reduces it for the volume change of the sand in the plastic zone under the tip. Sands of 50 to 80 % relative density have Ir of about 75 to 150.
Why does Vesic’s method need no limiting value?
Because the rigidity index itself falls as the stress at the tip grows. At φ′ = 35° and m = 250, Irr is 210.5 at q′ = 50 kPa and 26.3 at q′ = 400 kPa, so Nσ* falls with depth and qp grows more slowly than q′.
How does Vesic’s Nσ* compare with Meyerhof’s Nq*?
They enter the same kind of equation through Nσ* = 3Nq*/(1 + 2Ko). For the worked pile, Nσ* = 62.44 is equivalent to Nq* = 39.2, against Meyerhof’s 115.0; but Meyerhof’s limiting value brings his down to an effective 24.1 at that depth.