GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Settlement

Elastic settlement of a footing: immediate settlement in clay and sand

The settlement a shallow foundation undergoes as it is loaded: the elastic formula with Steinbrenner’s factors, the modulus of clay and of sand, the net pressure, layered ground and the depth down to which the soil is counted.

  • Free to read
  • Centre · corner · rigid
  • Layered soil
  • Worked example

1The formulaA flexible footing on elastic ground.

The immediate settlement of a footing B × L carrying a uniform net pressure qnet is written

S=qnetB(1−ν2)EI

E and ν are the modulus and Poisson’s ratio of the ground, and I is a dimensionless influence factor that depends on the shape of the footing, on the thickness H of the compressible ground below it and on the point considered. It follows from the theory of elasticity: Steinbrenner (1934) integrated the vertical strain below the corner of a uniformly loaded rectangle down to a rigid base, and the other points of the footing are sums of corner rectangles (see Steinbrenner influence factors):

Icentre=2Is(LB,2HB),Icorner=Is(LB,HB)

The footing is taken as perfectly flexible: it follows the ground, settling most at its centre and least at its corners. On deep ground a flexible square has I = 1.122 at the centre, 0.561 at a corner and 0.946 averaged over its area, the half-space values of Schleicher (1926). A rigid footing settles uniformly; the GeoTerva modules take its settlement as 0.93 times the flexible centre, which in most cases lies above the average settlement of the flexible footing (in the worked example below 14.2 mm against 12.3 mm) and so errs on the safe side.

2Undrained clay, drained sandWhich modulus and which Poisson’s ratio.

  • Clay and silt. A saturated clay is loaded far faster than water can leave it, so it first deforms at constant volume: the immediate settlement is a distortion, computed with the undrained modulus Eu and ν = 0.5. Then 1 − ν² = 0.75 and Steinbrenner’s Is reduces to F1. Eu is often related to the undrained shear strength, Eu = β·cu, with β from a few hundred to about 1500, lower for plastic and for heavily overconsolidated clays (Duncan and Buchignani, 1976). The volume change follows later, as the water drains: that is the consolidation settlement, a separate part.
  • Sand and gravel. A granular soil drains as it is loaded, so its settlement is the drained, elastic one, with E′ and ν′ ≈ 0.25–0.35; there is no consolidation to add. From the SPT blow count, E′/pa = α·N60 with α = 5 for sands with fines, 10 for clean normally consolidated sands and 15 for clean overconsolidated sands, pa ≈ 100 kPa (Kulhawy and Mayne, 1990). The modulus of a sand grows with depth: a thick layer is better entered as several layers of increasing E′.

3Net pressure and calculation depthWhat loads the ground, and how deep it is counted.

A footing placed in an excavation first unloads the ground by the weight of the soil removed. With one modulus for unloading and reloading, the rebound is recovered as the footing is loaded, so the settlement is governed by the net pressure:

qnet=qgross−σv0′(D)

σ′v0(D) is the effective overburden at the foundation level. The embedment itself stiffens the response a little; the depth factor of Fox (1948) expresses this, and the GeoTerva modules take it as 1, on the safe side.

The stress below a footing falls with depth but never vanishes, so the strain is summed down to a calculation depth: either the bottom of the compressible profile, where a rigid stratum (rock, dense gravel) stops the strain as in Steinbrenner’s solution, or the influence depth at which the stress increase under the centre has fallen to a fraction p of the pressure, 10 % being the common choice:

Table 1. Influence depth z′/B below the foundation level: Δσz under the centre = p·q
L/Bp = 10 %p = 20 %
12.091.40
1.52.551.70
22.921.94
33.512.28
54.332.68
105.443.03
strip6.343.13

Boussinesq’s stress below the centre of a uniformly loaded rectangle or strip. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its settlement modules use.

The influence depth grows with the footing: with p = 10 % a strip reaches 3.0 times as deep as a square of the same width. When the profile ends above the influence depth, the modules continue its last layer down to it.

4Layered groundEach layer with its own E and ν.

Ground is rarely one material. A layer between the depths zt and zb below the foundation level contributes the difference of Steinbrenner’s solution between its bottom and its top, with its own modulus and Poisson’s ratio:

ΔS=qnetαB′(1−ν2)E[Is(zbB′)−Is(ztB′)]

with α = 4, B′ = B/2 at the centre and α = 1, B′ = B at a corner. The sum over the layers replaces the weighted average modulus of a single-layer formula, and within a layer the result does not depend on how finely it is sliced. Table 2 shows what a modulus that grows with depth does: square footings of growing width at D = 1.0 m, all with qnet = 150 kPa, on a sand with E′ = 15 MPa to 4 m, 30 MPa to 9 m and 60 MPa below, ν′ = 0.3, against the same footings on a uniform sand of E′ = 30 MPa.

Table 2. Settlement of square footings B × B, qnet = 150 kPa, against the width (influence depth, p = 10 %)
B (m)zlim (m)S centre (mm)S corner (mm)S rigid (mm)S/B (mm/m)Uniform E′ = 30 MPa: S centre (mm)Uniform: S/B (mm/m)
13.097.93.07.47.914.03.96
1.54.1311.84.411.07.875.93.96
25.1715.05.414.07.517.93.96
37.2620.77.119.26.8811.93.96
49.3525.48.523.76.3615.83.96
613.5232.410.330.15.3923.73.96
817.7037.911.835.24.7331.63.96

zlim is measured from the ground surface. Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its elastic settlement modules.

On uniform ground the settlement grows in proportion to the width (S/B stays 3.96 mm/m). On the layered sand the 1 m footing stresses mostly the soft upper sand and settles 7.91 mm per metre of width; the 8 m footing reaches the dense sand and settles only 4.73 mm per metre. Under the same pressure a wide footing still settles more than a narrow one.

5Worked exampleA footing on two clay layers.

A footing B × L = 3.0 m × 4.5 m is founded at D = 1.0 m and carries a gross pressure of 200 kPa. The ground is a stiff clay, Eu = 40 MPa and γ = 19 kN/m³, down to 4 m, over a firm clay, Eu = 18 MPa; the water table is at 2.0 m. Both clays are loaded undrained, ν = 0.5.

  • Net pressure: qnet = 200 − 19 × 1.0 = 181.0 kPa.
  • Calculation depth: for L/B = 1.5 the stress under the centre falls to 10 % at z′ = 7.64 m below the foundation level (Table 1: 2.55B), so the clays are counted down to 8.64 m.
  • Centre (α = 4, B′ = 1.50 m, m′ = 1.50, Is = F1): the stiff clay spans z′ = 0–3.00 m, n′ = 2.000, Is = 0.2925, so S = 181.0 × 0.75 / 40000 × 4 × 1.50 × 0.2925 = 5.96 mm. The firm clay spans z′ = 3.00–7.64 m, n′ = 2.000 to 5.094, Is = 0.2925 to 0.4986: S = 181.0 × 0.75 / 18000 × 4 × 1.50 × (0.4986 − 0.2925) = 9.33 mm. Together 15.3 mm.
  • Corner (α = 1, B′ = 3.0 m): Is = 0.1319 at z′ = 3.00 m and 0.3534 at 7.64 m, S = 1.34 + 5.01 = 6.4 mm.
  • Rigid footing: 0.93 × 15.3 = 14.2 mm; averaged over its area, the flexible footing settles 12.3 mm.
Table 3. Immediate settlement of the worked footing, layer by layer
LayerDepth compressed (m)Eu (MPa)S centre (mm)S corner (mm)S average (mm)
Stiff clay1.0–4.0406.01.34.7
Firm clay4.0–8.64189.35.07.6
Total15.36.412.3

Average: Steinbrenner’s point factor integrated over the area of the footing. Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its elastic settlement modules.

The firm clay, softer and below the stiff one, gives 61 % of the settlement at the centre even though the stress has spread by the time it reaches it. Had the upper clay been as soft as the lower one (Eu = 18 MPa throughout), the centre would settle 22.6 mm. The consolidation of the two clays comes on top of these values (see total settlement of a foundation).

6QuestionsShort answers.

Is the immediate settlement of a clay really elastic?

It is the constant-volume distortion of the clay under a load applied faster than the clay can drain. It is computed with an elastic model, with the undrained modulus Eu and ν = 0.5, although part of it is not recovered on unloading. The volume change comes later, as consolidation.

What is the difference between the flexible and the rigid settlement?

A flexible footing follows the ground: on deep ground a flexible square settles 1.122·qB(1 − ν²)/E at its centre and half as much at its corners. A rigid footing settles uniformly; the GeoTerva modules take 0.93 times the flexible centre. The difference between centre and corner is the differential settlement of a flexible footing.

How deep should the settlement be summed?

Down to a rigid stratum when there is one, otherwise to the influence depth at which the stress increase under the centre has fallen to 10 % of the pressure: about 2.09B below a square footing, 2.92B below one with L = 2B and 6.34B below a strip.

The theory behind it