GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Consolidation

Consolidation settlement of clay: Cc, Cr, Cs and the preconsolidation pressure

How much a clay layer compresses as the water drains from it: the e–log σ′ formulas for normally consolidated and overconsolidated clay, the settlement of one metre of clay for every load and OCR, and the stress path of an excavation that is loaded again.

  • Free to read
  • NC and OC clay
  • OCR = 1–4
  • Worked example

1Normally consolidated clayThe compression index Cc.

When a saturated clay is loaded, the load is first carried by the pore water. As the water drains, the effective stress rises and the clay compresses: this is consolidation, the one-dimensional theory of which Terzaghi (1925) laid down. In an oedometer, the void ratio e of a clay that has never carried more than its present load falls along a straight line against the logarithm of the effective stress, the virgin compression line. Its slope is the compression index:

Cc=−ΔeΔlog10⁡σ′

A layer of thickness H and initial void ratio e0 shortens by ΔH = H·Δe/(1 + e0). For a stress increase Δσ′ at the middle of the layer, from the initial effective stress σ′0:

Sc=CcH1+e0log10⁡σ0′+Δσ′σ0′

σ′0 is the vertical effective stress before loading, from the unit weights and the water table, and Δσ′ the increase the foundation causes at that depth, from Boussinesq’s solution (see stress below a rectangular footing). Both change with depth, so a thick layer is divided into slices, each with its own σ′0 and Δσ′. The formula gives the final settlement, once all the excess pore pressure has dissipated; how long that takes is a separate question (see time factor and degree of consolidation).

2Overconsolidated clayCr up to σ′p, Cc beyond.

A clay that once carried a larger effective stress than today, under soil since eroded, a water table since raised, or through ageing, is overconsolidated. The largest stress it has carried is the preconsolidation pressure σ′p, read from the oedometer curve with the construction of Casagrande (1936); its ratio to the present stress is the overconsolidation ratio:

OCR=σp′σ0′

Up to σ′p the clay is reloaded along a much flatter line, with the recompression index Cr, commonly between a fifth and a tenth of Cc. It is often written Cs, the swelling index, because the unloading and reloading lines of a clay are nearly parallel. The GeoTerva modules keep the two apart, Cs for swelling on unloading and Cr for reloading, and take Cs = Cr when no Cs is given. With σ′f = σ′0 + Δσ′:

Sc=CrH1+e0log10⁡σf′σ0′if σf′≤σp′
Sc=CrH1+e0log10⁡σp′σ0′+CcH1+e0log10⁡σf′σp′if σf′>σp′

For OCR = 1 the clay is normally consolidated, σ′p = σ′0, and the second formula reduces to the first. A clay with OCR below 1 would still be consolidating under its own weight (under-consolidated) and is outside these formulas.

3Settlement of one metre of clayAgainst the stress increase, for OCR = 1–4.

The formulas depend on the stresses only through the ratios Δσ′/σ′0 and OCR. Table 1 gives the settlement of a clay layer 1 m thick with e0 = 1.0, Cc = 0.30 and Cr = 0.05, under a stress increase that is uniform over its thickness.

Table 1. Consolidation settlement of 1 m of clay (mm): Δσ′/σ′0 down, OCR across (e0 = 1.0, Cc = 0.30, Cr = 0.05)
Δσ′/σ′0OCR = 1OCR = 1.25OCR = 1.5OCR = 2OCR = 3OCR = 4
0.16.21.01.01.01.01.0
0.211.92.02.02.02.02.0
0.317.15.02.82.82.82.8
0.526.414.34.44.44.44.4
0.7536.524.314.46.16.16.1
145.233.023.17.57.57.5
1.559.747.637.722.19.99.9
271.659.549.633.911.911.9
390.378.268.352.730.715.1
4104.892.782.867.245.229.6
5116.7104.694.779.157.141.5

Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its consolidation module. The OCR = 1 column is proportional to Cc/(1 + e0) = 0.150 and can be scaled for another clay.

For a load that doubles the effective stress (Δσ′/σ′0 = 1), one metre of normally consolidated clay settles 45.2 mm; with OCR = 2 the clay only returns to its preconsolidation pressure and settles 7.5 mm, and with OCR = 3 the same 7.5 mm. Once σ′p is passed the settlement climbs quickly: with OCR = 2 and Δσ′/σ′0 = 3 it is 52.7 mm. Knowing σ′p is therefore as important as knowing Cc.

4Excavation and reloadingThe stress path the module follows.

Most foundations sit in an excavation, and the clay below sees an unloading before it is loaded. The GeoTerva consolidation module follows that stress path slice by slice, never in one step from the initial to the final stress:

σ0′→σexc′→σ0′→σp′→σf′(Cs,Cs,Cr,Cc)
  • Excavation. The excavation removes the effective overburden at its base, qremoved = σ′v0(D). At a depth z′ below it the stress falls by qremoved·I(z′), with Boussinesq’s factor I of the excavated plan, to σ′exc, and the clay swells along Cs: ΔH = −Cs·H/(1 + e0)·log(σ′0/σ′exc).
  • Loading. The foundation adds q·I(z′): σ′f = σ′exc + q·I(z′). The clay first retraces its swelling line back to σ′0 (Sb, with Cs: the heave is recovered), then recompresses with Cr up to σ′p (Sr) and compresses along the virgin line beyond it (Sv, with Cc).
Sc=Sb+Sr+Sv,S=Sc+Sheave

σ′p is the historical maximum and is not lowered by the excavation. The unloading–reloading loop closes at σ′0, so a load that only restores the removed overburden causes no settlement relative to the original ground. Measured from the original ground, the settlement is S = Sc + Sheave, the compression beyond σ′0; measured from the heaved base of an excavation left open long enough for the heave to develop, it is Sc, which includes the recompression of the heave. The module reports both.

5Worked exampleA raft on a soft clay over a firm clay.

A raft B × L = 10 m × 14 m is built in an excavation of its own plan, D = 1.5 m deep, and carries a gross pressure of 85 kPa. The water table is at 1.5 m. Below the clayey fill that is dug out lie:

  • 1.5–8 m soft clay: γsat = 17.8 kN/m³, e0 = 1.15, Cc = 0.38, Cr = Cs = 0.06, OCR = 1.25, cv = 1.5 m²/year;
  • 8–30 m firm clay: γsat = 19 kN/m³, e0 = 0.82, Cc = 0.24, Cr = Cs = 0.04, OCR = 1.8, cv = 2.5 m²/year; sand below 30 m.

Each clay is taken as drained at its top and at its bottom (double drainage).

The excavation removes qremoved = 27.0 kPa (net pressure 58.0 kPa). The clays are counted down to the influence depth, 26.13 m, in slices of 0.5 m. One slice of the soft clay, 4.5–5.0 m:

  • σ′0 = 52.97 kPa at z = 4.75 m, σ′p = 1.25 × 52.97 = 66.21 kPa.
  • Excavation: I = 0.9037 at z′ = 3.25 m, σ′exc = 52.97 − 27.0 × 0.9037 = 28.57 kPa; with H/(1 + e0) = 0.5/2.15 = 0.2326 m the slice heaves 0.06 × 0.2326 × log(52.97/28.57) = 3.74 mm.
  • Loading: σ′f = 28.57 + 85 × 0.9037 = 105.38 kPa, above σ′p. Sb = 3.74 mm (the heave recovered), Sr = 0.06 × 0.2326 × log(66.21/52.97) = 1.35 mm, Sv = 0.38 × 0.2326 × log(105.38/66.21) = 17.84 mm.
  • Measured from the original ground the slice settles Sr + Sv = 19.19 mm: its compression beyond σ′0.
Table 2. Consolidation settlement of the worked raft, layer by layer (mm)
LayerDepth compressed (m)HeaveSbSrSvScS = Sc + Sheave
Soft clay1.50–8.00−67.867.817.6243.3328.8260.9
Firm clay8.00–26.13−10.710.719.70.030.319.7
Total−78.578.537.2243.3359.1280.6

Every slice of the soft clay passes its preconsolidation pressure; every slice of the firm clay stays below it. Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its consolidation module.

Measured from the original ground the raft settles 280.6 mm, 93 % of it in the soft clay; measured from the heaved excavation base, 359.1 mm. The firm clay, with OCR = 1.8, is only recompressed and adds 19.7 mm over 18.1 m. With double drainage the soft clay has Hdr = 3.25 m and reaches 90 % consolidation in T90·Hdr²/cv = 0.848 × 3.25² / 1.5 = 6.0 years; the two clays together reach 50 % of Sc after 1.5 years and 90 % after 7.5 years.

6QuestionsShort answers.

What is the difference between Cc, Cr and Cs?

They are slopes of the e–log σ′ curve of a clay: Cc on the virgin compression line, beyond the preconsolidation pressure; Cr on reloading below it; Cs on unloading (swelling). Cr and Cs are much smaller than Cc and are often taken equal.

How is the settlement of an overconsolidated clay found?

With Cr from σ′0 up to σ′p = OCR·σ′0, and with Cc beyond it. If the final stress stays below σ′p, only Cr applies: doubling the stress of one metre of clay with e0 = 1, Cc = 0.30, Cr = 0.05 gives 45.2 mm when normally consolidated but 7.5 mm with OCR = 2.

How long does consolidation take?

Terzaghi’s theory gives t = TvHdr²/cv, with Tv = 0.197 for 50 % and 0.848 for 90 % consolidation, cv the coefficient of consolidation and Hdr the drainage path (see the time factor). The settlement itself does not depend on cv.

The theory behind it