GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Pile foundations

Pile end bearing in clay: 9cu, Vesic and the drilled shaft

The point resistance of a pile in undrained clay by three routes: Meyerhof’s fixed qp = 9cu, Vesic’s factor from the rigidity index, and Reese and O’Neill’s rule for a drilled shaft, with tables for cu = 8–500 kPa.

  • Free to read
  • cu = 8–500 kPa
  • Meyerhof · Vesic · Reese–O’Neill
  • Worked example

1Point bearing in clayqp = N*ccu.

In a saturated clay loaded undrained the friction angle is zero, and the net unit point resistance of a pile is a bearing-capacity factor times the undrained shear strength of the clay at the tip:

qp=Nc*cu,Qp=Apqp

Ap is the area of the pile tip. Only the clay at and just below the tip enters: the clay the shaft passes through belongs to the shaft resistance. For a driven pile of ordinary size the point is usually a small part of the capacity in clay, the shaft carrying most of it (see the α method), but for a large bored pile it can be a large part. The three routes below differ in N*c and in the cu they take.

2Meyerhof: qp = 9cuThe fixed factor of nine.

Skempton (1951) showed that the bearing-capacity factor of a circular or square foundation on clay rises with depth and levels off at about 9 once the foundation is a few widths deep: the failure zone no longer reaches the surface. Meyerhof (1976) took that deep value for piles:

Nc*=9,qp=9cu

It needs nothing beyond cu at the tip and does not depend on the depth, provided the pile is deep. In firm and stiff clay it is the more conservative of the two driven-pile routes.

3Vesic: N*c from the rigidity indexCavity expansion.

Vesic (1977) derived the factor from the expansion of a spherical cavity in an elastic–plastic soil. For φ = 0:

Nc*=43(ln⁡Irr+1)+π2+1

Irr is the reduced rigidity index. A saturated clay sheared undrained does not change volume, so Irr = Ir = G/cu, with G the shear modulus. O’Neill and Reese (1999) relate it to the strength alone:

Ir=347cupa−33≤300

With this approximation N*c depends only on cu. It is below nine in soft clay, passes nine near cu = 23 kPa and reaches 11.51 when Ir reaches its cap of 300, at cu = 96 kPa; above that it stays constant. Below cu = 9.8 kPa Ir falls under 1 and the logarithm loses its meaning: Vesic’s route does not apply to so soft a clay.

4A drilled shaft: Reese and O’NeillA base of its own.

The base of a bored pile (drilled shaft) is cast on soil that has been unloaded and may carry some debris, and it needs a larger settlement than a driven pile to develop its resistance. Reese and O’Neill (1989) give a rule of its own for a drilled shaft in clay:

qp=6cub(1+0.2LDb)≤9cub≤40pa

cub is the mean undrained strength over a depth of 2Db below the base, Db the base diameter and L the depth of the base. The factor rises from 6 at the surface to 9 at L/Db = 2.5 and stays there; the second ceiling, 40pa ≈ 4 MPa, governs only in very stiff clay. A wide base would need an unacceptable settlement to reach qp, so for Db greater than 1.91 m the value is reduced:

qp,r=Frqp,Fr=2.5c1Db+c2≤1

with c1 = 2.78 × 10−4 + 8.26 × 10−5(L/Db) ≤ 5.9 × 10−4 and c2 = 0.065√cub, 0.5 ≤ c2 ≤ 1.5 (Db in mm, cub in kPa). The same procedure changes the shaft as well: see the drilled-shaft rule of the α method.

5Tablesqp against cu, L/Db and Db.

Table 1. Unit point resistance qp (kPa) against cu, pa = 100 kPa
cu (kPa)Meyerhof qp = 9cuVesic IrVesic N*cVesic qpDrilled shaft qp, L/Db = 10
872———72
10901.74.614690
1513519.07.83118135
2018036.48.70174180
2522553.89.22230225
3027071.19.59288270
40360105.810.12405360
50450140.510.50525450
60540175.210.79648540
75675227.311.14835675
90810279.311.411027810
100900300.011.511151900
1251125300.011.5114391125
1501350300.011.5117261350
2001800300.011.5123021800
2502250300.011.5128772250
3002700300.011.5134532700
4003600300.011.5146043600
4504050300.011.5151794000
5004500300.011.5157554000

— : Ir ≤ 1, Vesic’s route does not apply. Drilled shaft: Reese and O’Neill (1989) with cub = cu, Db ≤ 1.91 m, so no reduction for a wide base. Values computed by GeoTerva with the functions its pile modules use.

Table 2. Drilled shaft: factor qp/cub against L/Db (cub = 100 kPa)
L/Db6(1 + 0.2L/Db)qp/cub usedGoverned by
06.006.006(1 + 0.2L/Db)
0.56.606.606(1 + 0.2L/Db)
17.207.206(1 + 0.2L/Db)
1.57.807.806(1 + 0.2L/Db)
28.408.406(1 + 0.2L/Db)
2.59.009.006(1 + 0.2L/Db)
39.609.009cub
512.009.009cub
1018.009.009cub
Table 3. Drilled shaft: reduction factor Fr for a wide base (L = 20 m)
Db (m)cub = 50 kPacub = 100 kPacub = 200 kPacub = 400 kPa
2.01.0001.0001.0001.000
2.51.0001.0001.0000.901
3.01.0001.0000.9300.814
3.50.9750.9210.8380.743
4.00.8740.8310.7620.683
5.00.7250.6940.6460.588

Fr = 1 for Db ≤ 1.91 m. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its pile modules use.

6Worked exampleA driven pile and a drilled shaft in the same clay.

The ground is clay in three layers: 0–8 m with cu = 45 kPa, 8–16 m with cu = 80 kPa, and from 16 m down cu = 130 kPa. Both piles end at L = 15 m, in the middle layer.

  • Driven precast pile, 0.4 m square: Ap = 0.160 m², cu at the tip = 80 kPa. Meyerhof: qp = 9 × 80 = 720 kPa, Qp = 0.160 × 720 = 115.2 kN. Vesic: Ir = 347 × 0.80 − 33 = 244.6, N*c = 4/3(ln 244.6 + 1) + π/2 + 1 = 11.24, qp = 899 kPa, Qp = 143.8 kN.
  • Drilled shaft, Db = 1.2 m: the zone 2Db below the base runs from 15 to 17.4 m: 1.0 m of the 80 kPa clay and 1.4 m of the 130 kPa clay, so cub = (80 × 1.0 + 130 × 1.4)/2.4 = 109.17 kPa. L/Db = 12.50, and 6cub(1 + 0.2L/Db) = 2293 kPa exceeds 9cub = 982.5 kPa, so qp = 982.5 kPa. Db ≤ 1.91 m, so Fr = 1. With Ab = 1.131 m², Qp = 1111 kN.

Meyerhof’s 9cu with the strength at the tip would give the same drilled shaft only 814 kN: the drilled-shaft rule gives more here because it averages over the stiffer clay just below the base. The shaft resistance is added to the point to give the capacity; the pile capacity in clay module of GeoTerva works out both, with Meyerhof’s or Vesic’s point for a driven pile and Reese and O’Neill’s for a bored one.

7QuestionsShort answers.

Why is the point bearing of a pile in clay 9cu?

Below a deep foundation the failure zone cannot reach the ground surface, and the bearing-capacity factor of a deep circular or square base in undrained clay levels off at about 9 (Skempton, 1951). Meyerhof (1976) adopted N*c = 9 for piles, so qp = 9cu.

Which cu is used for the point resistance?

The undrained strength of the clay the tip bears on. For a driven pile it is the strength at the tip; for a drilled shaft by Reese and O’Neill it is the mean over 2Db below the base. The strength of the clay along the shaft does not enter the point resistance.

Does Vesic’s method always give more than 9cu?

No. With Ir = 347cu/pa − 33, N*c is below 9 for cu under about 23 kPa and reaches 11.51 from cu ≈ 96 kPa upwards; below 9.8 kPa the route does not apply at all.

The theory behind it