GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Laterally loaded piles

Coefficient of subgrade reaction nh and kh: the elastic pile under lateral load

The springs of the elastic solution of a laterally loaded pile: nh for a sand, kh for a clay, the relative stiffness T and R, the coefficients of Matlock and Reese, and how far the elastic answer stays from the p–y one as the load grows.

  • Free to read
  • nh · kh · T · R
  • Matlock & Reese (1960)
  • Worked example

1The coefficient of subgrade reactionSprings that grow with depth, or stay constant.

In the subgrade-reaction model the ground beside a laterally loaded pile is a row of independent elastic springs (Winkler). At the depth z the soil reaction p, a force per unit length of the pile, is proportional to the deflection y there:

p=k(z)y

k (kN/m²) is the stiffness of the spring per unit length of the pile. Two forms of it are in use. In a sand, whose stiffness grows with the confining stress, k is taken to grow in proportion to depth (Terzaghi, 1955; Reese and Matlock, 1956), and in a clay it is taken as constant with depth, from the coefficient of horizontal subgrade reaction kh of the soil and the width D of the pile:

k=nhz(sand),k=khD(clay)

nh, the constant of horizontal subgrade reaction, and kh are both in kN/m³ (or MN/m³). The GeoTerva laterally loaded pile module carries this model as its elastic option, a sand layer with p = nhzy and a clay layer with p = khDy, in any order of layers; its main option is the non-linear p–y curve (see p–y curves for sand and clay).

2Values of nh and khFrom the literature, and what they stand for.

Sand. Terzaghi (1955) proposed nh of about 2.2, 6.6 and 17.6 MN/m³ for a loose, medium-dense and dense sand that is dry or moist, and about 1.3, 4.4 and 10.7 MN/m³ for the same sands submerged. The initial modulus k of the sand p–y curve (Reese, Cox and Koop, 1974; API RP 2A) is the same quantity, the slope of the reaction at a vanishing deflection: about 5.4, 16.3 and 34 MN/m³ for a loose, medium and dense sand below the water table and 6.8, 24.4 and 61 MN/m³ above it. The GeoTerva module fills it in from φ′ by a fit to the API chart, for instance 10.5, 32.7 and 61.7 MN/m³ above the water table at φ′ = 30°, 34° and 38°.

The two sets differ by a factor of about three to four because they stand for different things. The k of the p–y curve is a tangent at the origin, used with a curve that softens as the soil yields; Terzaghi’s nh is a single value meant for the whole range of working loads, a secant that already allows for some yielding. Used in a linear analysis, nh has to be chosen for the load and the deflection expected (chapter 5 shows how the equivalent nh of a pile falls as its load grows).

Clay. For a clay the stiffness is commonly related to the undrained shear strength; Davisson (1970) suggested kh ≈ 67cu/D, that is k = khD ≈ 67cu, independent of the width of the pile. It can also be derived from the Young’s modulus of the soil (Vesic, 1961). Such values hold for the small strains of working loads; at larger loads a p–y curve is the better model.

3Relative stiffness T and RThe length over which the pile works.

The pile and the springs together have one characteristic length. With k = nhz it is the relative stiffness factor T of Reese and Matlock, with a constant k the length R (Davisson and Gill, 1963):

T=(EInh)1/5,R=(EIk)1/4=(EIkhD)1/4

Depths are measured in these lengths, Z = z/T. A pile whose length L is at least 5T behaves as an infinitely long one: its tip does not move and its length no longer matters (the coefficients of Matlock and Reese do not change beyond L/T = 5). A pile shorter than about 2T moves as a rigid body. With a constant k, Hetényi’s long-beam condition βL ≥ π, with β = (k/4EI)1/4 = 1/(√2·R), means L ≥ 4.4R.

Table 1. Relative stiffness factor T (m) for k = nhz
PileEI (kN·m²)nh = 2 MN/m³nh = 5 MN/m³nh = 10 MN/m³nh = 20 MN/m³nh = 40 MN/m³
Precast concrete, 0.40 m × 0.40 m640002.001.671.451.261.10
Bored concrete, D = 0.60 m1908522.492.071.801.571.37
Bored concrete, D = 0.80 m6031863.132.612.271.981.72
Bored concrete, D = 1.00 m14726223.743.122.712.362.06
Bored concrete, D = 1.20 m30536284.333.613.142.732.38
Steel pipe, 0.61 m × 12.7 mm2232842.572.141.861.621.41

T = (EI/nh)1/5, computed here; EI of the uncracked section, E = 30 000 MPa for concrete and 210 000 MPa for steel. T changes slowly with nh: a factor of 20 in nh changes T by a factor of 1.82.

Table 2. Relative stiffness R (m) for a constant k = khD
PileEI (kN·m²)kh = 5 MN/m³kh = 10 MN/m³kh = 20 MN/m³kh = 40 MN/m³kh = 80 MN/m³
Precast concrete, 0.40 m × 0.40 m640002.382.001.681.411.19
Bored concrete, D = 0.60 m1908522.822.372.001.681.41
Bored concrete, D = 0.80 m6031863.502.952.482.081.75
Bored concrete, D = 1.00 m14726224.143.482.932.462.07
Bored concrete, D = 1.20 m30536284.753.993.362.822.37
Steel pipe, 0.61 m × 12.7 mm2232842.932.462.071.741.46

R = (EI/khD)1/4, computed here with the width D of each pile (0.40 m for the square pile).

4The elastic solution of Matlock and Reese (1960)Dimensionless coefficients of a long pile.

Matlock and Reese (1960) solved the beam on springs with k = nhz for a load H and a moment Mg at the ground surface and wrote the answer in coefficients of Z = z/T:

y=AyHT3EI+ByMgT2EI,θ=AθHT2EI+BθMgTEI
M=AmHT+BmMg,V=AvH+BvMgT

The table gives the coefficients of a long pile with the head free, computed by the engine of the GeoTerva module in its elastic mode; y is positive in the direction of the load, and a positive Mg adds to the deflection the load causes.

Table 3. Coefficients of the elastic solution, k = nhz, long pile, head free
Z = z/TAyAθAmAvByBθBmBv
0.002.429−1.6190.0001.0001.619−1.7471.0000.000
0.252.027−1.5890.2440.9321.214−1.4970.996−0.042
0.501.640−1.5000.4580.7630.871−1.2500.975−0.137
0.751.281−1.3640.6210.5370.588−1.0120.926−0.249
1.000.961−1.1940.7250.2940.363−0.7890.851−0.351
1.250.685−1.0060.7690.0650.192−0.5880.753−0.427
1.500.458−0.8140.760−0.1290.067−0.4140.640−0.470
2.000.141−0.4620.627−0.371−0.070−0.1530.404−0.456
2.50−0.020−0.1990.421−0.424−0.105−0.0050.200−0.350
3.00−0.075−0.0390.224−0.349−0.0890.0570.059−0.213
4.00−0.0500.0520.000−0.106−0.0280.049−0.042−0.016
5.00−0.0090.025−0.0330.0130.0000.011−0.0260.029

Computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its laterally loaded pile module (finite elements, a pile 12T long); Am peaks at 0.772 at Z = 1.33. With the head held against rotation, y0 = 0.928·HT³/EI and M0 = −0.927·HT.

Constant k (clay). With k constant the equation is that of a beam on an elastic foundation, and Hetényi (1946) gives the long pile in closed form. For a load H at the ground surface:

y0=2Hβk,Mmax=e−π/4sin⁡π4Hβ=0.322Hβatz=π4β(free head)
y0=Hβk,M0=−H2β(fixed head)

5Elastic against p–yOne pile, a range of loads.

A steel pipe pile, 0.61 m × 12.7 mm, L = 20 m (EI = 223284 kN·m²), stands in a dry sand with φ′ = 32° and γ = 18 kN/m³, the load at the ground surface and the head free. It is analysed twice by the engine of the module: with the API p–y curves of the sand, and with elastic springs whose nh is the initial modulus of those curves, k = 20.7 MN/m³ (T = 1.61 m, L/T = 12.4). The last column gives the nh that would make the elastic solution deflect as much as the p–y one at that load, from y0 = AyHT³/EI.

Table 4. The pipe pile under a lateral load: elastic springs (nh = k) against the p–y curves
H (kN)y0 elastic (mm)y0 p–y (mm)p–y / elasticMmax elastic (kN·m)Mmax p–y (kN·m)Equivalent nh (MN/m³)
100.450.451.0012.412.420.7
251.131.141.0031.031.120.6
502.272.291.0162.162.620.3
1004.534.741.04124.2127.919.2
1506.807.511.10186.3198.917.6
2009.0610.801.19248.4278.515.5
30013.6019.911.46372.5474.211.0
40018.1333.101.83496.7719.27.6

Values computed by GeoTerva with the engine of its laterally loaded pile module; the equivalent nh from T = (y0EI/AyH)1/3, nh = EI/T5.

At small loads the two solutions coincide: every p–y curve starts on its elastic tangent kzy. As the load grows the sand near the surface reaches the bent part of its curve, the p–y deflection runs ahead of the elastic one, and the equivalent nh falls, from 20.7 MN/m³ at 10 kN to 7.6 MN/m³ at 400 kN. A single nh fits one load only, which is why a linear analysis needs a value chosen for the deflection expected, and why the p–y method is used in design.

6Worked exampleThe pipe pile with nh = 8 MN/m³, then in a clay.

The pipe pile of Table 4 (EI = 223284 kN·m², L = 20 m) carries H = 150 kN at the ground surface, head free. For the sand an engineer takes nh = 8 MN/m³.

  • Relative stiffness: T = (223284 / 8000)1/5 = 1.946 m; L/T = 10.3 ≥ 5, so the pile is long.
  • Head deflection: y0 = AyHT³/EI = 2.429 × 150 × 1.946³ / 223284 = 12.03 mm.
  • Largest moment: Mmax = AmHT = 0.772 × 150 × 1.946 = 225.3 kN·m at z = 1.33T = 2.59 m. The module in its elastic mode, with the same nh, gives 12.03 mm and 225.3 kN·m at 2.59 m.
  • Against the p–y curves: at 150 kN the p–y solution deflects 7.51 mm (Table 4), the deflection of an elastic pile with nh = 17.6 MN/m³. The chosen 8 MN/m³ overestimates the deflection at this load by 60 %; at 400 kN the equivalent value has come down to 7.6 MN/m³.

In a clay. The same pile in a clay with kh = 20 MN/m³: k = khD = 20 × 0.61 = 12.20 MN/m², R = (EI/k)1/4 = 2.068 m and β = 1/(√2·R) = 0.3419 m⁻¹; βL = 6.84 ≥ π, a long pile.

  • Free head: y0 = 2Hβ/k = 2 × 150 × 0.3419 / 12200 = 8.41 mm; Mmax = 0.322 × 150 / 0.3419 = 141.5 kN·m at z = π/(4β) = 2.30 m. The module, elastic: 8.41 mm and 141.5 kN·m at 2.30 m.
  • Fixed head: y0 = Hβ/k = 4.20 mm, half the free value, and the cap holds M0 = H/(2β) = 219.4 kN·m; the module gives 4.20 mm and 219.4 kN·m.

How the deflection and the moment of a pile change from the elastic range to large loads on p–y springs is the subject of deflection and bending moment of a laterally loaded pile.

7QuestionsShort answers.

What are the units of nh and kh?

Both are a force per unit volume, kN/m³ or MN/m³. The spring stiffness per unit length of the pile, k in kN/m², is nhz in a sand (it grows by nh for every metre of depth) and khD in a clay. Some authors call k itself the modulus of subgrade reaction; check which of the two a value refers to before using it.

Why are Terzaghi’s nh values lower than the k of the p–y curve of a sand?

The k of the p–y curve is the initial tangent of a curve that softens; Terzaghi’s nh is a single value for the working-load range, which already allows for some yielding of the soil. In Table 4 the nh that matches the p–y deflection falls from 20.7 to 7.6 MN/m³ as the load rises from 10 to 400 kN.

When is a laterally loaded pile long, and when rigid?

With k = nhz a pile is long when L ≥ 5T, and moves as a rigid body when L ≤ 2T, T = (EI/nh)1/5. With a constant k it is long when βL ≥ π (L ≥ 4.4R). The deflection and the moment of a long pile do not depend on its length.

The theory behind it