GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Braced cuts

Apparent earth pressure for braced cuts: Peck’s envelopes and the strut loads

The pressure envelopes from which the struts of a braced excavation are designed: sand, soft to medium clay and stiff clay, the stability number that decides between the clays, and the strut loads by the hinge method, with every ordinate tabulated.

  • Free to read
  • Sand · soft clay · stiff clay
  • γH/c = 2–12
  • Worked example

1Why an apparent pressureEnvelopes of measured strut loads.

The sheeting of a braced cut is propped by struts as the excavation goes down, and it deforms in a way no classical earth-pressure theory describes: the top hardly moves once the first strut is in, the lower part moves more, and the pressure behind the wall is redistributed towards the struts. Peck (1943) measured the strut loads in the cuts of the Chicago subway; later measurements in sand and clay led to the envelopes of Peck (1969).

Each measured strut load was converted into an apparent pressure by dividing it by its tributary area, and the envelopes were drawn to cover the apparent pressures of all the cuts. An envelope is therefore not the real distribution of earth pressure at any one time: it is a design tool, chosen so that the load read from it for any single strut is on the safe side. It is not used to find the total thrust on the wall or the embedment of the sheeting.

2The three envelopesSand, soft to medium clay, stiff clay.

Sand. A uniform pressure over the full depth H of the cut:

σa=0.65γHKa,Ka=tan2(45°−φ′2)

(see earth pressure coefficients). Clay. Which envelope applies is decided by the stability number γH/c, c being the undrained shear strength:

γHc>4:σa=γH[1−4cγH]or0.3γH, whichever is larger
γHc≤4:σa=0.2–0.4γH

The soft-to-medium clay envelope rises linearly from zero at the surface to σa at 0.25H and stays constant to the base. The stiff (fissured) clay envelope rises over the top quarter, is constant over the middle half and falls back to zero over the bottom quarter; the GeoTerva module takes 0.3γH, the middle of Peck’s range, unless another value is entered. A uniform surcharge beside the cut is not folded into the envelope, which was measured without one: it is added as its own lateral pressure, Kaq in sand and q in clay.

3Strut loads by the hinge methodEach piece of sheeting a determinate beam.

To turn the envelope into strut loads, the sheeting is assumed to be hinged at the strut levels, except the top and the bottom ones. Each piece between the hinges, the surface and the base is then a determinate beam on the struts it contains — an overhanging beam where it reaches the surface or the base, a simple span between two hinges — and its reactions follow from statics. A strut at a hinge collects a reaction from the piece on each side. The load in a strut is the reaction per metre of wall times the horizontal spacing s of the struts:

Pi=Ris

This is the inverse of how the envelopes were read from the measured loads. If the arrangement asks an inner strut to pull, which a strut cannot do, the GeoTerva module hinges the sheeting at every strut instead. The same pieces give the bending moment of the sheeting, and the wales, spanning between the struts, are designed for about Ris²/8.

In clay the first strut should sit above the depth of the tension crack, zc = 2c/γ.

4Tables of the envelopesDimensionless ordinates and resultants.

Table 1. Cut in sand: σa = 0.65γHKa
φ′ (°)Kaσa/(γH)Resultant/(γH²)
280.3610.2350.235
300.3330.2170.217
320.3070.2000.200
340.2830.1840.184
360.2600.1690.169
380.2380.1550.155
400.2170.1410.141

Rankine Ka; the envelope is uniform, so its resultant per metre of wall is σaH. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its braced-cut modules use.

Table 2. Cut in clay: the envelope by the stability number γH/c
γH/cEnvelopeσa fromσa/(γH)Resultant/(γH²)
2stiff clayk γH, k = 0.30.3000.225
3stiff clayk γH, k = 0.30.3000.225
4stiff clayk γH, k = 0.30.3000.225
4.5soft to medium clay0.3 γH0.3000.262
5soft to medium clay0.3 γH0.3000.262
5.5soft to medium clay0.3 γH0.3000.262
6soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.3330.292
7soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.4290.375
8soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.5000.438
9soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.5560.486
10soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.6000.525
12soft to medium clayγH(1 − 4c/γH)0.6670.583

Soft to medium clay: zero at the surface to σa at 0.25H, constant to the base (resultant 0.875σaH). Stiff clay: trapezoid over 0.25H–0.75H (resultant 0.75σaH), k = 0.3. Values computed by GeoTerva.

Up to γH/c = 4/0.7 ≈ 5.7 the soft-clay envelope is held at its minimum 0.3γH; beyond it the term 1 − 4c/γH governs and grows quickly: at γH/c = 8 the plateau is 0.50γH, against 0.30γH at 5.5. Near γH/c = 4 the envelope changes shape although its plateau does not, so a small change of c moves the design from one envelope to the other.

5Worked exampleA 10 m cut in soft clay, three struts.

A cut H = 10 m deep is made in a clay with γ = 18.5 kN/m³ and c = 32 kPa. Struts A, B and C are placed at 1.5, 4.5, 7.5 m below the surface, at s = 3.0 m centres along the cut.

  • Stability number: γH/c = 18.5 × 10 / 32 = 5.78 > 4: soft to medium clay.
  • Envelope: γH(1 − 4c/γH) = 185.0 × (1 − 4 × 32 / 185.0) = 57.00 kPa, against 0.3γH = 55.50 kPa: σa = 57.00 kPa, from zero at the surface to σa at 2.50 m. Its resultant is 498.7 kN/m.
  • First strut: the tension crack reaches zc = 2 × 32 / 18.5 = 3.46 m; strut A at 1.5 m lies above it.
  • Hinges: the sheeting is hinged at every strut except the top and the bottom one, which gives the pieces below.
Table 3. The pieces of sheeting and their reactions (per metre of wall)
PieceBeamLoad W (kN/m)Reactions (kN/m)
0.0–4.5 moverhanging beam185.25A (z = 1.5 m): 105.29; B (z = 4.5 m): 79.96
4.5–10.0 moverhanging beam313.50B (z = 4.5 m): 26.12; C (z = 7.5 m): 287.37

Each piece is solved by moments about one support and the sum of the forces. Values computed by GeoTerva.

Table 4. Strut loads: the clay cut, and the same struts in a sand cut (φ′ = 34°, γ = 18 kN/m³, σa = 33.08 kPa)
StrutDepth (m)R, clay (kN/m)P = R s, clay (kN)Wale moment Rs²/8, clay (kN·m)R, sand (kN/m)P = R s, sand (kN)
A1.5105.3316118.5111.6335
B4.5106.1318119.352.4157
C7.5287.4862323.3166.8500

Strut spacing s = 3.0 m. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its braced-cut modules use.

Strut C carries the most, 862 kN, because it holds the whole 2.5 m below it as an overhang; the largest moment in the sheeting, 178.1 kN·m per metre, is at z = 7.50 m. Lowering strut C or adding a fourth level evens the loads out. The base of the same cut must also be checked against heave: here γH/c = 5.78 (see bottom heave of a braced cut in clay). The braced cut modules of GeoTerva take the struts, the sheeting and the wales through to the steel sections and check the base against heave or piping.

6QuestionsShort answers.

What is an apparent earth pressure envelope?

A pressure diagram drawn to enclose the apparent pressures back-figured from strut loads measured in real braced cuts (each load divided by its tributary area). It is used only to design the struts, wales and sheeting, not as the actual earth pressure on the wall.

Which envelope applies to a cut in clay?

It depends on the stability number γH/c. Above 4 the soft-to-medium clay envelope applies, σa = γH(1 − 4c/γH) but at least 0.3γH; at or below 4 the stiff clay envelope, σa = 0.2–0.4γH, applies.

Why does the bottom strut often carry the largest load?

With hinges at the inner struts, the bottom strut carries its share of the span above it and the whole of the sheeting below it down to the base as an overhang. A lower bottom strut, or an extra level, reduces it.

The theory behind it