GeoTerva Open the module

Formulas and tables · Braced cuts

Bottom heave of a braced cut in clay: the factor of safety

Whether the base of a deep excavation in soft clay will heave: the factor of safety against bottom heave, the effect of a firm stratum below the base and of the length of the cut, and FS for every stability number from 3 to 9.

  • Free to read
  • γH/c = 3–9
  • H/B = 0.25–2
  • Worked example

1The mechanismA bearing failure in reverse.

The clay beside a braced cut stands higher than the clay in its base. The weight of a strip of soil next to the cut, with any surcharge on it, presses on the clay at the level of the base, and if that clay is too soft it is squeezed sideways under the sheeting and up into the excavation: the base heaves. It is a bearing-capacity failure turned upside down — the loaded strip is the soil beside the cut and the “footing” bears at the level of the base.

Terzaghi (1943) took the strip as wide as the failure surface allows, B′ = B/√2 for a cut of width B, and let it carry the overburden γH and the surcharge q. Its downward movement is resisted by the shear c along the vertical plane through the clay beside the cut, and the clay below the base supplies the bearing capacity. With Terzaghi’s bearing factor 5.7 and the side shear taken off the load:

FS=5.7cγH+q−cHB′

Bottom heave is a short-term (undrained) failure, so c is the undrained shear strength of the clay.

2The factor of safetyThe form revised by Chang (2000).

Chang (2000) revised Terzaghi’s check: the side shear is counted as a resistance rather than taken off the load, the bearing factor is Prandtl’s 5.14 for a strip, and a shape term accounts for a cut of finite length L in plan. This is the form the GeoTerva braced-cut modules use:

FS=5.14c(1+0.2B″L)+cHB′γH+q
B′=Tif T≤B2otherwise B′=B2,B″=2B′

T is the depth of a firm stratum below the base of the cut. For a long cut (L → ∞) with no firm stratum within reach, B′ = B/√2 and the factor of safety takes a simple form in two numbers, the stability number γH/c and the ratio H/B:

FS=5.14+2H/BγH/c(long cut, q = 0)

A factor of safety of at least 1.5 is usually required (the GeoTerva module compares FS with 1.5 by default). The embedment of the sheeting below the base is not credited, which is on the safe side; on a layered profile the module takes the clay below the base for the bearing term and the strength averaged over the height of the cut for the side shear.

3A firm stratum, and the length of the cutB′ = T, and the shape term.

A firm stratum at a depth T < B/√2 below the base cuts the failure surface short: the strip that drives the heave narrows to B′ = T, the side shear cH/B′ grows and so does FS. Driving the sheeting into such a stratum is a common remedy for a base that would otherwise heave.

A short cut gains strength from its ends: the term 1 + 0.2B″/L raises the bearing part by a fifth for a square excavation with no firm stratum (B″ = B = L), and falls to 1 for a long trench.

For deep cuts Bjerrum and Eide (1956) treated the base as a deep footing, FS = cNc/(γH + q), with Skempton’s (1951) Nc increasing with the depth ratio H/B and with the plan shape; the GeoTerva modules use the Terzaghi–Chang form above.

4Tables of the factor of safetyBy γH/c and H/B, by T and by L.

Table 1. FS against bottom heave of a long cut with no firm stratum and no surcharge: γH/c down, H/B across
γH/cH/B = 0.25H/B = 0.5H/B = 0.75H/B = 1H/B = 1.5H/B = 2
31.831.952.072.182.422.66
41.371.461.551.641.821.99
51.101.171.241.311.451.59
60.920.971.031.091.211.33
70.780.840.890.941.041.14
80.690.730.780.820.911.00
90.610.650.690.730.810.89

B′ = B/√2. Values below 1 (in italics) mean the base heaves. Values computed by GeoTerva with the function its braced-cut modules use.

The factor of safety depends far more on the stability number than on the shape of the cut: at γH/c = 6 and H/B = 0.5 it is only 0.97. In a soft clay with c = 20 kPa and γ = 18 kN/m³, γH/c reaches 6 at a depth of only 6.7 m.

Table 2. The firm stratum: H = 8 m, B = 10 m, c = 40 kPa, γ = 18 kN/m³, long cut, q = 0
T (m)B′ (m)B′ fromFS
0.50.50T5.87
1.01.00T3.65
2.02.00T2.54
3.03.00T2.17
4.04.00T1.98
5.05.00T1.87
6.06.00T1.80
none (or T ≥ B/√2)7.07B/√21.74

Values computed by GeoTerva.

Table 3. The length of the cut in plan: the same cut, no firm stratum
L/BL (m)1 + 0.2B″/LFS
1.0101.20002.03
1.5151.13331.93
2.0201.10001.88
3.0301.06671.84
5.0501.04001.80
10.01001.02001.77
long cut—1.00001.74

B″ = √2B′ = B with no firm stratum. Values computed by GeoTerva.

5Worked exampleA cut 12 m wide and 7 m deep, a firm stratum 4 m below the base.

An excavation B = 12 m wide and L = 30 m long in plan is taken H = 7 m deep in a clay with c = 35 kPa and γ = 18 kN/m³ (γH/c = 3.60). A surcharge q = 10 kPa acts beside the cut, and a firm stratum lies T = 4 m below the base.

  • Width of the strip: B/√2 = 8.49 m > T, so B′ = T = 4.00 m and B″ = √2 × 4.00 = 5.66 m.
  • Shape term: 1 + 0.2 × 5.66 / 30 = 1.0377.
  • Resistance: 5.14 × 35 × 1.0377 + 35 × 7 / 4.00 = 247.93 kPa.
  • Load: γH + q = 18 × 7 + 10 = 136.00 kPa.
  • Factor of safety: FS = 247.93 / 136.00 = 1.82 ≥ 1.5.

Without the firm stratum, B′ would be B/√2 = 8.49 m and FS = 1.64; and as a long trench of the same section, with the firm stratum, FS = 1.77. The struts of the same cut are designed from the apparent pressure envelope (see apparent earth pressure for braced cuts); the braced cut in clay module of GeoTerva carries out both, layer by layer.

6QuestionsShort answers.

What is bottom heave?

The upward movement of the base of an excavation in soft clay when the clay below the base fails under the weight of the soil beside the cut, like a bearing failure in reverse. It is checked with the undrained shear strength in the short term.

What factor of safety against bottom heave is required?

Usually at least 1.5; the GeoTerva braced-cut modules use 1.5 by default. For a long cut with no firm stratum, FS = (5.14 + √2 H/B)/(γH/c), so FS falls below 1.5 when γH/c exceeds about (5.14 + √2 H/B)/1.5.

How does a firm stratum below the base help?

It limits the depth of the failure surface: the strip of soil that drives the heave narrows from B/√2 to the depth T of the stratum, and the side shear cH/B′ grows. Driving the sheeting into the firm stratum is a common remedy.

The theory behind it